Zusammenfassung der Ressource
Assessment for
DS
- Deconstruction
- Step 1: Summarize the
main points, comparing
headline to the story
- Step 2: Did the reporter
open the freezer? Is the
evidence direct or
indirect?
- Step 7 Is the story fair?
Is balance called for?
What about fair play
and language?
- Step 6 Are the key
questions answered?
(Who-What-When-
Where-Why-How)
- Step 3: Evaluate the
sources using
IMVAIN
- IMVAIN: A
SYSTEM FOR
EVALUATING THE
RELIABILITY OF
SOURCES
- Independent
sources are better
than
self-interested
sources
- Multiple sources are
better than single
sources
- Sources who Verify with
evidence are better than
sources who assert
- Authoritative/Informed
sources are better than
uninformed sources
- Named sources
are better than
unnamed
sources
- Step 5: Does the
reporter place the
facts, the story, in
context?
- Step 4: Does the
reporter make
his/her work
transparent?