128945
Factors Affecting
Eyewitness Testimony
- The role of emotion
- when someone either witnesses or
is the victim of a crime, they are
liable to feel intense emotions
- fear and anger being the main 2
- Deffenbacher (2004) found that high stress
had a negative impact on accuracy
- Christianson and Hubinette (1993)
found that witnesses to real bank
robberies who had been
threatened had better recall than
onlookers who were not involved
- Christianson and Hubinette (1993)
found that witnesses to real bank
robberies who had been
threatened had better recall than
onlookers who were not involved
- however, MacLeod (1986) compared
real life eyewitness reports of 379
physical assaults with crime where no
physical injury occurred
- found that there was no overall difference in
accuracy between the 2 types of crime
- found that there was no overall difference in
accuracy between the 2 types of crime
- fear and anger being the main 2
- Flashbulb memories
- vivid, long-lasting memories
which occur at times of
heightened emotion
- EG. JFK's assassination
and 9/11
- EG. JFK's assassination
and 9/11
- however, Talarico and Rubin
(2003) found that consistency for
flashbulb memories and everyday
memories do not differ
- however, PP's rated their
recall of 9/11 as being much
more vivid, and had a greater
confidence in its accuracy
- however, PP's rated their
recall of 9/11 as being much
more vivid, and had a greater
confidence in its accuracy
- vivid, long-lasting memories
which occur at times of
heightened emotion
- Nolan and Markham (1998)
found that confident witnesses
were seen as more accurate than
unsure witnesses, even though
the actual accuracy may not differ
- Weapon focus
- research has suggested that
witnesses often focus on a weapon
at the expense of other details
- Johnson and Scott (1978) had PP's
witness a man carrying a knife with
blood whilst waiting for an experiment,
and other PP's saw a man carrying a
pen covered in grease
- 49% of PP's with the 'pen'
could identify the man, 33%
with the 'knife' could identify
- 49% of PP's with the 'pen'
could identify the man, 33%
with the 'knife' could identify
- research has suggested that
witnesses often focus on a weapon
at the expense of other details
- when someone either witnesses or
is the victim of a crime, they are
liable to feel intense emotions
- Reconstructive memory:
Leading questions
- leading questions affect recall
because they provide 'post event'
info which is integrated with info
of the original perception
- a criticism of Loftus+Palmer's
study is that judging speed is
complex, therefore PP's are
more prone to being led by
leading questions
- Loftus+Zanni (1975) - asked one
group "Did you see A broken
headlight" and the other "Did you
see THE broken headlight"
- 7% reported they saw "A broken headlight",
17% said they saw "THE broken headlight"
- demonstrates that leading questions can
actually cause PP's to remember
something that was not there
- demonstrates that leading questions can
actually cause PP's to remember
something that was not there
- 7% reported they saw "A broken headlight",
17% said they saw "THE broken headlight"
- however, Loftus (1979) used
leading questions to try and alter
PP's recall of the colour of a purse
- PP's persisted in describing the purse as red
- PP's persisted in describing the purse as red
- much research is highly
artificial as it takes place
under lab conditions
- issues with
generalisability
- Yullie and Cuthshall
(1986) showed that the
effect of leading
questions is diminished
in real life situations
- issues with
generalisability
- however, research into the effect of
leading questions has led to the
development of the cognitive interview
- used by the police, structured in a
way that avoids leading questions to
maintain accuracy of EWT
- used by the police, structured in a
way that avoids leading questions to
maintain accuracy of EWT
- leading questions affect recall
because they provide 'post event'
info which is integrated with info
of the original perception
Want to create your own Mind Maps for free with GoConqr? Learn more.