Three negative definitions - when
you're not dishonest
D believes he
has a right in
law to deprive
the other of it:
s.2 (1) (a)
D believes he
would have the
other's consent if
he knew the
circumstances: s.2
(1) (b)
D believes the
person to whom the
property belongs
cannot be found by
taking reasonable
steps: s.2 (1) (c)
Belief has to be
genuine, but not
reasonable: SMALL
If none of the definitions apply,
the GHOSH test is used.
Does the jury think that Ds
actions were dishonest by the
standards of an ordinary honest
person?
Does the jury think that D would
have though his actions would
be dishonest by those
standards?
Appropriation s.3
Any assumption of the
rights of an owner.
Can be any of the
rights, only have to
assume one: MORRIS.
If property is acquired
innocently, it can later be
appropriated by D keeping
it or assuming the rights of
the owner.
There can be an
appropriation where the
owner has consented to D
taking it: GOMEZ
There can be an
appropriation where the
owner has legally gifted
the property: HINKS
Property s.4
Property includes money
and all other property,
personal and real,
including things in action
or other intangible
property: s.4 (1)
Money means coins and banknotes
Real property is land. This can be stolen if:
D removes topsoil or
trees.
D, as a tenant,
removes fixtures,
e.g. a kitchen
cupboard
Personal property includes all
movable items, including body
parts where they have been
treated for teaching purposes:
KELLY AND LINDSAY
Wild creatures are not
personal property
unless hey have been
tamed or are normally
kept in captivity: s.4 (4).
Picking mushrooms,
flowers, foliage is theft if
it is taken for sale, a
reward or other
commercial use: s.4 (3).
A thing in action is a right
enforced against another,
e.g. a right to copyright or
a trademark.
Intangible property
refers to things
which do not exist in
a physical sense, e.g.
patent.
Belonging to another s.5
Any person having possession
or control of it or having any
proprietary right or interest:
s.5 (1)
It is possible to steal your
own property if it is under
the possession or control of
someone else: TURNER No.2
Can be in control of
something even when they
do not know it's there:
WOODMAN
If money is handed to D
for a particular purpose,
the money still belongs to
V: s.5 (3): DAVIDGE v
BUNNETT/ HALL
Where property is received
by mistake and there is a
legal obligation to give it
back, then it still belongs to
another:
ATTORNEY-GENERALS
REFERENCE (No 1 of 1983)
Property does not belong to
another where it has been
abandoned.
Intention to permanently deprive s.6
Will have intention to
permanently deprive if he
picks property up, changed
his mind and puts the
property back: VELUMYL
Even if they do not intend
for V to lose the property
permanently, but has the
intention to dispose: s.6
Applies where D intends to sell v's
property back to V: DPP v
LAVENDER
Borrowing money is not theft.
It can be where it is for a period of time
making it an outright taking.
Where D borrows property and intends to
return it in such a changed state that all it's
goodness, virtue or practical value has gone:
LLOYD