Bixler obtained an option on a building he believed was suitable for use by a corporation he and two other individuals were organizing. After the corporation was successfully promoted, Bixler met with the board of directors, who agreed to acquire the property for $200,000. Bixler deeded the building to the corpor¬ation and the corporation began business in it. Bixler’s option contract called for the payment of only $155,000 for the building and he purchased it for that price. When the directors later learned that Bixler paid only $155,000, they demanded the return of Bixler’s $45,000 profit. Bixler refused, claiming the building was worth far more than $200,000 both when he secured the option and when he deeded it to the corporation. Which of the following statements correctly applies to Bixler’s conduct?
Select one of the following:
-
A. It was improper for Bixler to contract for the option without first having secured the assent of the board of directors.
-
B. If, as Bixler claimed, the building was fairly worth more than $200,000, Bixler is entitled to retain the entire price.
-
C. Even if, as Bixler claimed, the building was fairly worth more than $200,000, Bixler nevertheless must return the $45,000 to the corporation.
-
D. In order for Bixler to be obligated to return any amount to the corporation, the board of directors must establish that the building was worth less than $200,000.