Created by Alice Storr
almost 8 years ago
|
||
Number of people found to be wrongly convicted by March 1940
Number of cases out of 40 where unreliable EWT was to blame
Estimator variables
System variables
The year of the Ronald Cotton case
The person who was guilty, not Ronald Cotton
What is Post Event Information?
What is the reconstruction principle?
Why do schemas cause unreliable EWT?
Study where 70 ppts were asked to give the race of the man who they thought was holding the razor - more than half said that it was the black man
Asking ppts what speed cars were going when they 'hit' each other rather than 'smashed into' each other determined the ppts judgement of speed
Asking ppts if they had seen 'the' broken headlight rather than 'a' broken headlight increased likelihood that ppts said yes
Findings show that you can have highly accurate and reliable recall despite leading questions
Yerkes-Dobson Law
MacLeod 1986
The greater the arousal, the more accurate the testimony
Those who saw a violent film had worse recall than those who saw a non-violent film (2 studies have this format)
Founder of weapon focus theory
Is more or less attention focussed on a weapon due to survival instincts, therefore reducing accuracy of recall?
Counter argument from Pickel 1998
Maas & Kohnen 1989
Loftus 1987 eye fixation data
Loftus 1987 main finding
witnesses to a real armed robbery of a bank had accurate and reliable recall even 15 months after the event
Strongest evidence for unreliability due to weapon focus provided by Steblay 1992 - what were his findings?