church combines elements: structure,
contents, cultural meanings
Christian understanding of
world shaped/represented
by visual and material
surroundings
medieval church = combo
between visual arts and
devotional performance
1 EARLY GOTHIC AT
ST DENIS
pointed arches - taller-
Gothic (from German)
royal burials - coronation regalia -
relics of Saint Denis
SUGER - wanted light + furnishings - best
materials- effects rather than building itself
enhance worldy and spiritual power - route to divine - use of
building = metaphor (St Paul) - apostles and prophets =
foundations, JC = cornerstone
earthly world to spiritual world - enlightnement
gold, semi precious
stones/gems - stained glass
rebuilt
from 1130s
2 METHODS AND THEORIES FOR
UNDERSTANDING MEDIEVAL GREAT
CHURCH ARCHITECTURE
group 'great' churches of
similar style - share
architectural forms - 'formal
analysis' - enable
comparisons between
buildings
widen context for evidence
on decision making during
building - cult of a saint to
support Kingship of
England
evidence doesn't focus on uses, forms and
especially meanings of a building
holistic approach - how building made to work for
communities (religious and secular) they served - political,
secular needs and interests of patrons and communities
Historian Lindsay Jones - 3 uses of sacred architecture:
ORIENTATION - helps with understanding rel of universe
and earth COMMEMORATION - memorial or home of
relics/homage to saint (miracles) RITUAL CONTEXT -
performance, contemplation, propitiation (pleasing the
saints/god/jesus by offerings/confession), sanctuary
Secular elements: heraldry
- carved into stone -
presence of donor families
or civic involvement:
political hierarchy and
authority
SUGERS COMMISSION - NEW END OF SAINT DENIS
chevet -
semi-circle behind altar - ambulatory - chapels - made
wider in rebuild due to previous overcrowding
exterior shows flow of chapels - Suger may have told builders
what building should DO rather than what it should LOOK LIKE
names of builders
not recorded
Suger did not record evolution of building
amalgamation of different masons,
master carvers ideas and opinions
rather than 1 single concept
east end spiritually powerful - high altar -
JC due to return from the east
OTHER EXAMPLES
AUXERRE- rebuilt from 1215 - compete with
others around - accommodate growing
congregations - prestige for bishop/patrons -
building not sacred but acquired sacred purpose
REIMS - similar details to Westminster
Abbey - important for master builders -
Henry de Reynes had worked on it - rebuilt
1211 - 1250s
based on latin cross - some predictable
relationships eg nave = 2x width of aisles - altar
faces east - main door west - variations =
crossing may have tower above- choir in
non-monastic churches - screen separates
clergy from laity
clerestory,
triforium,
main arcade,
springing,
shaft
extra windows and height =
more light - higher ceilings
(roman churches darker, lower)
areas separated by pillars - vaulted ceilings with
ribs - decorated west exterior -
Furnishings
fixtures or fittings - screens to subdivide areas (sep. clergy from
laity) - laity not able to go further than nave - lots of altars for
different saints - endowed by individuals or guilds or institutions -
donors buying speedy route to heaven - each altar had art - stained
glass, altar retable, frontal, textiles, metalwork, vessels
4 WESTMINSTER ABBEY
Saint Ed the C;s shrine
behind altar - royal
tombs - ambulatory -
monastic buildings and
cloisters to south -
rebuilding 1246
St Peters - consecrated 1065 -
Edward the Confessor - Harold II -
William the Conq 1066 - Henry III
(1216 - 72)
Henry III rebuilding begun 1246 with
Henry de Reynes
SIGNIFICANCE OF
ROYAL PATRONAGE
paid for by Henry III -
most "lavishly finished
church of 13th C -
coronations - shrine to
Saint Edward (ex king) -
repository for royal
regalia - royal burial
place
although monastic, most important
uses = secular main uses
FRENCH AND
ENGLISH
GOTHIC AT
WESTMINSTER
ABBEY
Gothic dominant 1100 - 1500 - DECORATED GOTHIC= 13th C
England = window tracery - effects of light - apparent lack of load
bearing walls - definiing G characteristics
'rayonnant' = radiating - re complex tracery of rose/round
windows from 1230 plus arched windows
design resulting from masons travelling in Europe and
sharing/experimenting for different patrons
AESTHETIC
PROPERTIES OF
WESTMINSTER
ABBEY
high nave - chevet - rose window - height ratio of
arcade:triforium;clerestory same as at Amiens
tracery in gallery like Sainte-Chapelle Paris
relics of Christ - crown of thorns
MULTIPLE
MEANINGS AT
WESTMINSTER
ABBEY
Henry III au fait with French
court culture (M Eleanor of
Provence) - poss wanted to
emulate Fr. cathedrals - set on
total effect rather than particular
style distinctions - aware of Louis
IX's influence in Paris
material and spiritual seem to be
considered of equal importance