Identity: A social identity
means how your identity is
shown in society, and seen by
others.
Ethnicity
Hybrid Identity
Someones sense of who
they are is a mixture of
two or more influences.
Seen most clearly
within ethnicity,
nationality and
identity.
Very common
for second and
third
generation
immigrants.
Grow up in one
culture but retain
influences on their
identity from their
culture of origin.
Labels to describe
such hybrid identities
have been developed.
'Brasian' -
British and
Asian.
'Blasian' -
black and
Asian.
Also found in the white
British population, due
to the influence of
immigration and global
culture.
'white wannabes' - Nayak (2003) -
white British males who dress, act
and speak in a way that is
influenced by black hip hop
culture.
'Multicultural London English'
often called 'Jafaican
style of speech and accent used in
particular areas of London by young
white people, influenced by
African-Caribbean speech and accent
Product of the
multicultural nature
of parts of London,
where mixed groups
of white and black
young people
influence each
other, creating a
hybrid dialect.
Ethnicity is related to our
culture as is made up of our
religion, language, where we live,
our origin, skin colour etc. These
characteristics affect who we are
and how we see ourselves.
In the UK we identify certain
ethnic groups by their shared
cultural characteristics although
this is often problematic.
Second, third and fourth generation
migrants and those of mixed race will
also have a range of cultural
characteristics making their identity
more complex.
Ethnic identity
intersects with other
aspects of identity,
making everyone's
experience slightly
different.
Ghumann (1999) found
tradition, religion and
family values played an
important part in the
upbringing of
second-generation Asians
in the UK and Asian
children tend to be
socialised into the extended
family, with emphasis on
duty, loyalty and religious
commitment.
Gilroy (1993) looked at identity of
young black people, arguing the use of
the term 'Black Atlantic' to describe an
identity which was not specifically
rooted in the UK or their country of
origin and was shared with young black
people in the US. He argued the shared
experience of racism can transcend
differences in background and history
to create a 'black' identity.
Hewitt (2005) considers the white
'backlash' against multiculturalism.
Policies designed to achieve equality
have been seen as unfair to the white
community. A white working class
person have often reacted with anger
at perceived 'positive discrimination'
in favour of ethnic minorities, feeling
the need to defend their ethnic
identity.
In contemporary UK society, expansion of the
European Union means growing numbers of
ethnic minorities are white, with an ethnic
origin from Central or Eastern Europe. They
may face similar issues relating to racism that
immigrants from parts of Asia and the
Caribbean faced in previous decades.
Cashmore and Troyna (1990) argue there will
be tendency for ethnic minorities to 'turn
inwards' and seek support from their own
ethic community as a response to racism.
Thus, religion and culture may be
strengthened ad they become key sources of
identity and support.
Winston James (1993) suggests the experience of
racism unified the culture and identity of
African-Caribbeans in the UK. There was cultural
differences based on their island of origin and may
have also been divided based on the darkness of
skin, a hierarchy of colour imposed by colonialism. A
shared oppositional culture grew, organised around
the label 'black' as a resistance to racism.
Ethnic identities may be becoming more hybrid, as all people are
influenced by each other's cultures and by the media.
Modood (1997) found generational
difference over the issue of identity,
second-generation ethnic minorities from
both African-Caribbean and Asian
background felt much more British than
their parents.
Postnmodernists may argue that in a globalised and
media-saturated society, identity is all about choice - everyone can
create their own identity. The hybridity means ethnicity is
becoming less clear-cut and less significant. However, some
disagree saying that ethnicity and race are still sources of
discrimination and hugely affect identity.
Gender
Gender identity is fluid and changing. It is
socially constructed. The way women are seen
and the expectations surrounding their
appearance, behaviour and roles have all
changed in the last 100 years. Male identity is
also changing however. Traditionally there
were clear ideas of what was meant by
femininity and masculinity, but today there are
many ways to be a woman or a man.
Biological View
Wilson (1975) says the need to
reproduces requires men to be more
promiscuous. Women, however, need to
nurture one child and stay faithful to
the father f their child to esnsure his
help in its upbringing.
Functionalist View
Parsons (1955) says
females have and
'expressive role'. This is
natural and based on
their child bearing role,
but its reinforced by
socialisation. Men have
an 'instrumental role;
that of the
breadwinner and
protector. This is also
natural, based on their
physical strengthm
and reinforced through
socialisation. These
roles are functional for
the family.
Most sociologists argue
that gender identities
are socially
constructed, learned
through socialisation
but also changeable.
Gender roles gives us
collective
consciousness.
Oakley (1981)
Ann Oakley is a feminist
who argues that gender
roles are socially
constructed through
socialisation,
Manipulation: Encouraging
behaviour that is seen as
stereotypically acceptable
for the child's gender and
discouraging behaviour that
is not considered the norm.
Canalisation: Parents channelling
their child's interests into toys,
games and activities that are
considered the more for their
gender.
Verbal Appellation: Giving children
nicknames or pet names that reinforce
gender expectations.
Different Activities: Encourage children to
participate in activities around the home that
reinforce stereotypes.
Social Construction of Gender Identities
Feminists argue that gender
identity is socially constructed by
patriarchal society.
Hey (1997) studied friendship groups among
teenage girls and looked at the power the
female peer group has over girl's behaviour, and
how the norms of the female peer group are
rooted in patriarchy and expectations of how
girls should be.
Mac an Ghaill (1994) looked at how boys learn to
be mean in their peer groups at school, policing
their own and other's sexuality.
Hyper-masculinity was the main source of identity
for the 'macho lads' identified by Mac an Ghaill,
who valued the '3Fs'
Femininities
There are a range of feminine identities in
contemporary UK including the traditional
and the less traditional; housewife and
mother but also breadwinner and single
mother. However, today, feminine identity is
related to a passive or submissive role,
associated with a lack of self-confidence and
ambition. Feminists argue that this is learned
through socialisation, and there is evidence to
suggest that this may be changing.
'Laddishness' refers to masculine
behaviour, typically involving sportiness,
hardness, hanging out and not making an
effort at school. Jackson (2006) found that
some 'ladettes' also spent time drinking,
swearing and disrupting lessons, for the
fear of doing otherwise and being
considered unpopular or 'uncool'.
Denscombe (2001) looked at the increase
in female risk-taking behaviour as being
related to a 'ladette' culture, where young
women want to be seen as anything but
the stereotype of a woman.
Masculinities
Connell (1995) argued there are a range
of masculine identities, but the
hegemonic masculinity (dominant,
macho, aggressive) is the most common
and the one which is reinforced most
strongly. Other forms such as
subordinate masculinity, which he links
to homosexual males, and marginalised
masculinity, which he inks to
unemplpyed men, are present but not
fully accepted as 'real' masculinity.
Mac an Ghaill (1994) used the term
'crisis of masculinity' to refer to the
insecurity felt by working class men.
There has been a loss of the
'breadwinner' identity with the decline of
traditional male industries.
Canaan (1996) researched working class men
in Wolverhampton. She questioned both
those who were employed and those in long
term unemployment and found interesting
differences in their views of masculinity. Men
who had jobs gave fairly predictable
responses relating to fighting,d drinking and
sexual conquests. However, the unemployed
men said having a job was the most important
thing, and that they felt emasculated due to
their unemployment.
Hegemonic masculinity and
aggressive masculinity.
Hegemonic is socially desirable
(middle class).
Gender supports capitalism.
Women reproduce, maintain and
support capitalism because of
gender role socialisation.
Class
A group who share a
similar economic
and social situation.
It will clearly
affect the
economic
circumstances of
an individuals
upbringing, and
related issues
such as housing,
health and
schooling.
A social class develops similar norms
and values, cultures and lifestyles.
Class identity can be seen as a product of
socialisation, started in the family, and related
to cultural characteristics such as education,
occupation, lifestyle and taste.
Bourdieu (1984, 1986)
Class fractions determined by
varying degrees of social,
economic and cultural capital.
The ruling class has the power to
shape which attributes are valued,
and are in a position to pass on
capital to their children.
Cultural Capital: the knowledge,
attitudes skills, education and
advantages that a person has, which
gives them higher status.
Social Capital: resources based on group membership, relationships, influences and support.
Cultural capital is the most
significant for Bourdieu. Parents
transmit attitudes and knowledge
needed to be successful. Those
with high cultural capital will be in
a position to accumulate other
forms of capital as well.
The power of the ruling class
that allows them to define the
knowledge and skills that are
valued, ensuring they are in the
best position to aquire them,
giving them an unfair
advantage
When judging a social class you
make look at a persons
money/income, their
lifestyle/leisure/hobbies and
their occupation.
The upperclass are those with inherited
wealth. They operate a 'social closure' meaning
their education and leisure is seperated and
partially invisible to the rest of the population.
This group is waning in numbers and power,
and the new 'super rich' (achieved) status are
now much more significant.
The middle class are the majority of the population. They
are associated with those with professional or
managerial careers. They are likely to have been
university-educated and own their own homes. However,
these features apply to more of the population as the
access to them has spread. Fox (2004) highlights the
differences within the middle class (upper middles,
middle middles, lower middles) It is unlikely that
everyone who's middle class shares a similar experience
or identity.
The working class was
traditionally made up of manual
workers and those with trades.
Hutton (1995) says the decline in
trade union memberships and the
manufacturing sector has eroded
the working class identity. The
working class are often
romanticised as hard working and
straight talking,. Skeggs (1997)
studied working class women who
were embarrassed by how others
judged them due to their working
class background. Women made
strenuouse effort to show they
were 'respectable'.
The underclass is a controversial term and is
unlikely that many people identify themselves
as a member. It was firstly used who identify
those who lacked opportunities and were at the
very bottom of society. It is now used in a
negative way to describe those who rely on
benefits and are blamed for their situation due
to their own choices. Governments are
unsurprisingly concerned about this group and
groups such as NEETs (young people not in
education, employment or training). These
groups are portrayed in a negative way in the
media on shows such as 'The Jeremy Kyle Show'
, 'Shamless' and 'Benefits Street'.
Pakulski and Waters (1996) suggest
a shift from production to
consumption in the definition of
identities - now defined by what we
buy, not what we do. Offe (1985)
says fewer individuals share a
common, unifying experience of
full-time work which used to shape
the culture of social class. We are all
able to create our own identities
regardless of the social class of our
family or job we have at one time.
Contemporary UK gives choices
and opportunities to everyone.
The media also gives access to an
endless range of information and
cultural experiences, breaking
down many social and class-based
barriers that may have used to
exist.
Not everyone would agree that
society today is as class-free as it
seems. Social class background
remains the most significant
indicator of outcomes such as
education and there is a lot of
evidence suggesting a difference in
culture and lifestyle between people
from different social and economic
backgrounds.
Age
Only aspect of identity for
which we will all experience
the changing effects.
Age is often looked at as a stage in the life
course. The problem with looked at these
stages is that the ages at which they start and
end vary and individuals will also differ.
Childhood
In some cultures, childhood is not seen as
a period of innocence, dependence or
vulnerability. Instead children would be
working and sometimes fighting as armed
soldiers. Marriage may be considered at
the age of 12/13 for girls.
We have a contradictory view with childhood
in the UK. In the media, children are portrayed
as either vulnerable victims or delinquents.
It is a held view that children 'grow up' more
quickly today but actually until the mid-twentieth
century, childhood lasted for a shorter time.
People were usually working and even having
families of their own before their eighteenth
birthday.
Postman (1982)
Childhood emerged only when
the spread of literacy enabled
adults to better shield children
from various aspects of adult
life, so the 'innocent' child was
created.
The emergence and spread of media
has brought about a decline in
childhood and threatens, to bring
about its disappearance.
Youth
Youth is socially constructed
as a period of transition from
childhood to adulthood and a
time of rebellion/resistance.
Some cultures have no
concept of youth,
childhood ends one day
and adulthood begins.
Margaret Mead (1928) argued 'storm
and stress' associated with youth is
culturally specific and not found in all
cultures.
Young adulthood and middle age
Young adulthood is normally characterised by career and
family. Most people form relationships, have children and
establish their careers, often moving into their own homes
and becoming independent.
Middle age associated with those in their forties and fifties.
Bradley (1996)
A higher status than
youth or old age,
middle aged people are
running the country
and hold power at
work.
Also seen as a negative time, as
'youth' is lost and old age come closer.
It is sometimes associated with
negative ideas, such as 'mid life crisis'
and 'empty nest syndrome'
Old Age
UK culture admires youth and the
beauty of youthful bodies. In
contrast, ageing bodies represent
ugliness and degeneration. Older
people have been socialised into this
view themselves.
Corner (1999) The language used
by older participants about their
own identity was mostly negative,
reflecting that used by media and
popular culture. They described
the problems of old age for society
and the 'burden' if the ageing
population. They were concerned
with becoming a 'burden'
themselves and the dominant
stereotype they present was of
being a time on ill-health and
dependency in later life.
Hockey and James (1993) -
Growing Up and Growing Old
Children are seen to lack status
of person-hood and are
separated from the public, adult
world and are confined to
'specialist places' for children,
such as schools. They are the
opposite of adults - dependent,
innocent, vulnerable - and
needing care and control.
Link age and childhood and argue they are
socially constructed in a similar way - lost
'person hood' . Terms such as 'gaga' are
related to babies, and the elderly are also
seen as helpless and needing care. This
concept is called 'infantilisation'
In their research in a
retirement home, clients
were treated like children
and their privacy was taken
away. They were assumed
to be quite innocent and
this created a self-fulfilling
prophecy. They argued in
most cases is was not based
on medical needs.
Featherstone and
Hepworth (2005) argue
the media's images of
ageing, which create
neaative stereotypes, can
also create new
identities.
Sexuality
Area of social
life that society,
and especially
the media,
seems obsessed
with.
Sexual identity
tends to be more
significant for
those who are not
hetreosexual.
Weeks (1987)
not many would say
'I am hetrosexual' in
relation to their
identity.
'I am gay' or 'I am lesbian'
makes a statement about
belonging and your
relationship to dominant
sexual codes.
McIntosh
(1996) - The
Homosexual
Role
In western cultures, the role
of homosexual male
involves certain
expectations of cultural
characteristics.
The homosexual role
may include effeminate
mannerisms, higher
voice and attention to
appearance.
Once a male
accepted the label or
identity of
'homosexual' he will
start to fulfill these
expectations, so the
label creates the
behaviour.
Married men
who see
themselves as
'straight' but
still admit to
attractions to
males, but do
not exhibit any
other 'signs' of
homosexuality.
Males she
studied who
were 'out' did
fulfill all of the
expectations
of the
homosexual
role.
Historically,
homosexuality
was considered a
mental illness that
needed to be
cured and even a
criminal offence in
the UK.
Attitudes have changed
significantly in British society
over the last 50 years, but in
some parts of the world
homosexuality is still illegal,
and homosexuals are till
denied basic human rights in
some places.
Reiss (1961)
Young male
prostitutes
regarded
themselves as
hetrosexual,
despite having sex
with men for
money, and they
actively despised
the men as a way
of netrualising the
behavioud
Plummer (1996) -
partially supports
McIntosh
Homosexuality is a process
and discussing the
'homosexual career' where
a male who has accepted
the label ill seek out others
and join a subculture, in
which stereotypical
characteristics become the
norm.
It is not actually sexual
attraction that creates
the 'homosexual'
acceptance and
internalisation of the
identity of 'homosexual'
Rich (1980)
Women's sexuality
is oppressed by
men in patriarchal
society, through
marriage, sexual
violence and the
sexual
objectification of
women.
Most women are not
necessarily inherently
hetrosexual, but that this is
forced upon them, and
lesbian existence is quite
distinct from homosexuality
in men.
Cross-cultural evidence
suggests that a distinct
homosexual identity is not
apparant in all cultures, and
that a sexual encounter
between two people of the
same sex is not uncommon, but
also not necessarily defined as
'homosexual'.
In the UK, attitudes to homosexuality have, at
least publicly, changed enormously in the last 30
years, which is likely to have a big impact on
sexuality and identity.
Homosexuality is no longer
classified a 'condition'; ages
of consent for sexual
intercourse was equalised in
2000, and the Equality Act
2010 makes it unlawful to
discriminate against any
individual on the grounds of
sexuality.