What were people complaining
about in the early 1780s?
1) The Tax System
Nota:
- 3rd estate paid brunt of taxation
- 1st and 2nd estates largely exempt, e.g. gabelle and taille
- Church only paid don gratuit
- 3rd estate therefore demanded reform- 85% of population!
2)Nobles Rights
Nota:
- feudal rights over peasants.... payments, seigneurial courts, hunting and fishing rights, monopoly of operating mills, ovens, winepresses etc.
- excessive privileges... tax exemptions, exempt from military service and corvée
- could buy your way into nobility (venality)- unfair and prevented meritocracy.... in 1749, nearly everyone with an income of over 1/2 a million were nobles in Paris
3)Corruption in the Church
Nota:
- Parish Priests not treated fairly.. e.g. problems with the tithe
- In 1789, all but one of the 135 bishops were of noble birth
- Some bishops more interested in pursuing political power... leading to absenteeism
- Many criticised this Church hierarchy and also the monarchy... as the monarchy supported the persecution of the Jansenists (Catholics who disliked power and corruption of Pope and bishops)
4) Corruption at court
Nota:
- The system of venality prevented meritocracy
- Tax collection was also collected by those under this system of venality and they could not be dismissed, therefore causing resentment as people paying taxes knew not all of their money wold reach the treasury
5) Life in towns
Nota:
- standard of living was very low... life expectancy at birth was a staggering 28.5 years!
- prices in grain were incredibly significant and rises could create huge unrest and public disorder as peasants largely relied on bread
MONTESQUIEU
Was of noble status and his
father was a minor nobleman
He therefore saw nobility's privileges as
necessary for protection against despotism
President of Parlement of Bordeaux
After retiring, travelled Europe and was
greatly influenced by the English system of
government
Wrote 'Lettres Persanes'... criticised aspects
of French society through the eyes of
foreigners to avoid censorship!
Wrote 'De L'Esprit des Lois'... identifying different types of
government and which gov. types would be suitable to
different types of society (immediately placed on RC index!)
MAIN IDEAS:
1) Noble Privileges necessary
2) Should be a balance of powers, i.e.
separation of powers to avoid
absolutism (favoured a CONSTITUTION)
Nota:
Ideas of a separation of powers cna be found in the American Constitution... the executive, the legislative and the judiciary
3) Disliked organised religion and mocked
principles of Catholicism
4) Believed in reform of criminals
5) Argued that arms races increased likelihood of war
and urged countries to stop
6) Argued that the State existed to protect the poor
VOLTAIRE
Lawyer
Nota:
He therefore upheld various campaigns against the abuse of laws
He too travelled the England and admired the
British constitution and society
Produced 'Candide'... criticising human
naivety, religion and 18th century warfare
MAIN IDEAS:
Wanted an absolute monarchy, but with
nobles/philosophers guiding the King
(enlightened despotism)
He didn't believe in equality, but he also didn't
agree with tyranny
Nota:
"No government can be effective unless it has absolute power"
Ultimately wanted to reduce power of RC Church
Nota:
"If God did not exist it would be necessary to invent him"
Favoured education of upper class
Great advocate of liberty
ROUSSEAU
lower class background
Revolution therefore heavily inspired by him
Hated classism and social inequality
Produced 'Emile'... a book about education, advocating the
need for education to be centred around the needs of the
child rather than to haul them into adulthood
Produced 'The Social Contact'... developed the concept
of the 'general will,' i.e. democracy
However, also realised that one person might know what is in everyone's best
interests and at times should impose general rules, i.e. dictatorship
Ideas have had a lasting impact...
Polish gov. asked for his advice on
how to reform their constitution
Robespierre tried to introduced
system of gov. based on the general
will- collapsed after one year
However... in 'Confessions' he admitted to being
a thief and having several illegitimate children!
PHYSIOCRATS AND TURGOT
Principally believed in Laissez-Faire, abolition of guilds,
monopolies, tariffs and wealthy privileges
Can be seen in implementation of free trade in grain and a single land tax
Wanted a strong monarch to maintain the
natural law of things... needed 'legal despotism'
to overcome forces of privilege
Believed efforts should be made to stimulate
natural products since the wealth of the Nation
depended on agriculture
Turgot........ followed physiocratic ideas
and became finance minister in 1774
Had the chance to put Physiocratic
ideas into practice and failed
However, concepts of laissez-faire were widely
accepted in the 19th century