Design Argument

Design Argument

Design qua purpose
1. Analogy of the Pocketwatch
  1. Know Pocketwatch was designed due to complexity and mechanical fucntion
    1. Nature is similar
      1. Photosynthesis, eye
      2. Must be designed - God
  2. Paley
2. Analogy of the Archer
  1. Aquinas
    1. 5th Way
  2. Arrow requires archer to guide it
    1. Inanimate objects cannot direct themselves
      1. Seeds, planets etc
      2. Must be directed - God
3. Anthropic Principle
  1. Tennant
  2. Evidence of universe supporting complex life
    1. Ozone layer
      1. Arthur Brown
    2. World was designed to support life - God
Design qua regularity
1. Aesthetic Principle
  1. Tennant
  2. Evolution cannot explain concept of beauty
    1. Must be desinged by loving God
2. Fine-tuning Argument
  1. Swinburne
  2. Universe is finely tuned to support life
    1. Laws of Physics
    2. Scinece cannot explain why these things exist
      1. Only that they do
      2. Too many conicidences for it to be chance
        Designed by God
3. Laws of nature
  1. Paley
  2. Planetary alignment and Laws of Physics
    1. Shows evidence of intelligent designer
      1. Pattern shows there must be a designer - God
Criticisms
1. Darwin
  1. Theory of Evolution
  2. Apparent design comes from millions of years of evolution
    1. We're adapted to the world - world is'nt adapted for us
2. Dawkins
  1. Evolution creates "illusion of design"
    1. Concept of beauty comes from cultural inheritance
      1. Memes
3. Kant
  1. Argument is based on experiance
    1. No experiance of creation
      1. Cannot claim it was created by God
4. Mill
  1. Natural evil exist
    1. Either God does not exist or
      1. Or he is not Omni-benevolant/Omni-potent

Siguiente

Descripción

Resumen del Recurso

Similar

	Creado por alexea56 hace más de 10 años