Leadership is a process whereby
intentional influence is exerted by 1
person (or a group) over other people
to structure the activities and
relationships in a group or organisation
Management vs Leadership
Leadership one aspect of Management
Mintzberg
Interpersonal skills:
Figurehead
Leadership
Liaison
Information skills:
Monitor
Disseminator
Spokesperson
Decisional roles:
Entrepreneur
Disturbance handler
Resource allocator
Negotiator
Management/Leadership differences:
Manager:
administers
maintains
systems & structures
relies on control
bottom line
does things right
Leader:
innovates
develops
focus on people
inspires trust
eye on the horizon
does the right things
Hollingsworth
Subordinate goals
Structure
Strategy
System
Skills
Staff
Style
McKinsey Seven S Framework
LEADERSHIP RELY ON:
MANAGEMENT RELY ON:
Watson
Bases of Power:
Reward Power
Nota:
based on the subordinate's perception that the leader has the ability to control rewards that the followers are looking for
Coercive Power
Nota:
Based on fear & the subordinate's perception that the leader has the ability to punish or to cause an unpleasant experience for those who do not comply
Referent Power
Nota:
Based on the subordinate's identification with the leader
Expert Power
Nota:
Based on the subordinate having the perception that the leader is someone who has access to information & relevant power
Legitimate Power
Nota:
Based on authority and not on personal power
French & Duncan
Leadership traits:
Strong drive for responsibility
Focus on task completion
Vigour and persistence in the pursuit of goals
Venturesomeness & originality in problem solving
Drive to exercise initiative in social settings
Self confidence
Sense of personal identity
Willingness to accept consequences of
decisions and actions
Readiness to absorb interpersonal stress
Willingness to tolerate frustration & delay
Ability to influence behaviour of others
Capacity to structure social
systems to the purpose at hand
Stogdill
Better than average on:
Ability
Sociability
Motivation
Leadership Style &
Behaviour Theory
Management &
Leadership style is
influenced by the
persons' assumptions
about human nature
McGregor's Theory X/Y
Theory X:
Negative view on human nature
Worker not motivated to work,
doesn't want to be there
Coercion & control the only way
to get people to work hard
Theory Y:
Positive view on human nature
Workers will actively seek responsibility
Leadership style one of
encouragement & facilitation,
encouraging creativity & innovation
Likert
Production centred
Leader pays close
attention to work of
subordinates
Employee centred
Leader is interested in developing
cohesive working groups & ensuring
that employees are satisfied
LBDQ
Nota:
Leadership Behaviour Description Questionnaire
Structure Behaviour
Formal lines of communication & control, leader
determines how tasks are performed
Consideration Behaviour
Leaders shows concern for their subordinates,
warm supportive climate
Blake
Contingency Theory
No single leadership style that is correct for every
situation, for every leader, in all circumstances
Fielder
Least-preferred co-worker
scale to identify style of leader
High score=people oriented
Low score=task oriented
Proposed that leader has to adapt style to suit situation, and success
of leader was related to knowledge of the maturity level of employees
4 levels of maturity:
Unable and unwilling
Unable and willing
Able and willing
Able and unwilling
Hershey & Blanchard
Leadership & management intervention is proposed to be on a
continuum dependent upon skills, expertise & experience of the group
Tannenbaum & Schmidt
Closer supervision for subordinates who are inexperienced or lacking in skills at first
Close attention & supervision reduces over time, once skills & experience have developed
Leaders must balance the needs of the Task, Team &
Individual, & vary the amount of attention he pays to each o
these 3 areas according to the requirements of the situation
Task element-setting clear objectives & expectations, &
managing processes required for people to follow
Team element-ensuring communication & interactions
between team members are smooth, & that workload is
balanced across the team
Individual element-considering the individual needs of
people & spending time & effort getting to know how
individuals are feeling
Transformational vs Transactional Leadership
Transformational
To transform people & orgs in a literal sense,
changing them in heart & mind, enlarging
their vision & clarifying purpose
Builds on need for meaning
Preoccupied with purpose,
values, morals & ethics
Transcends daily affiairs
Long term goals without
compromising human values
Focuses more on mission & strategy
Releases human potential-identifies talent
Designs & re-designs jobs to make
them challenging & meaningful
Aligns internal structures & systems to
reinforce overarching values & goals
Transactional
'Business as usual' where leaders gain their
workers' commitment to a task by rewarding
them in line with expectation of the role
Builds on the need for a man to get the job done
Is preoccupied with power, position, perks & politics
Is mired in daily affairs
Short-term & hard data oriented
Focuses on tactical issues
Relies on human relations to
lubricate human interactions
Follows & fulfils role expectations by striving
to work effectively within current systems
Supports structures & systems that maximise
efficiency & guarantee short-term profit
Covey
Path Goal Theory
Based on expectancy theory of motivation
Leader behaviour is acceptable & satisfying to followers
to the extent that they see it as an immediate source of
satisfaction or instrument to future satisfaction
Picks from:
Directive
Supportive
Participative
Achievement-oriented
House
Charismatic Leadership
Builds on transformational leaders,
the antidote to downturn
Able to motivate, rebuild morale
& promote strong vision for future
4 characteristics:
dominant personality &
desire to influence others
strong role model behaviour
articulation of ideological goals
high expectation of followers
& a confidence that
expectations will be met
Northouse
Servant & Team Leadership
Servant: Leader wishes to
serve his/her people, rather
than a desire to lead or
dictate
Team: Leaders knowing when to
follow, & importance of leader acting as
team facilitator rather than director
Knows when to ask questions
Chooses to delegate & share roles
Builds on & appreciates diversity
Seeks out talented people
Develops colleagues & creates a
sense of mission & purpose
Belbin
4 Types of Senior Teams:
Informational Teams
Consultative Teams
Coordinating Teams
Decision-making Teams
Wagerman, Fisher & Hackman
Distributed Leadership
All of us can exert a leadership
influence over colleagues, & in
turn influence the direction &
success of the org
Emphasises importance of
relationships
Focuses on everyone in the
org as being involved in the
org's future
Promotes the concept of
emergent leadership, orgs to
develop leaders throughout
org & not just at the top
Relies on ability of individual
to influence through their
social interactions & not
position
Emphasises outcomes of
effective leadership, rather
than ability of leaders to
prove themselves competent
in various skills
Strategic Organisational Leadership
Rational Strategy Formulation
Relies on predictability of events
Emergent Strategy
Formulation
Emphasises uncertain
conditions & involves
bringing in contingencies
Strategy Formulation
Pub Sec Differences:
Political changes
Leadership changes
CG interference
Variety of stakeholders
Key Pub Sec Drivers:
Reducing costs
Obtaining value for money
Characteristics of a
successful strategic manager:
Mixture of sensitivity & toughness
Nota:
Sensitivity to gauge both external & internal environments & to assess the risks of failure
Toughness to persist with strategies to ensure the org is moving in a purposeful direction
Wisdom to refrain from managing
components of the org but rather
provide leadership
mapping environ to org & org to environ
managing interplay bet tasks &
processes when change is required
Skill to spot leading edge of an activity
Public Sector Leadership
Structure
Lawful delegation of
authority & external controls
that leaders work within
Craft
Leaders' behaviours
& personality
Institution
Pub sec leader has strong opps
to devise strategy, based on
matching known external
demands with internal motivation
to achieve goals
Strategic Leadership
The ability to anticipate, envision, maintain
flexibility & empower others to create the
strategic change necessary
Exercising Power:
Mete out resources
Shape behaviour
through reward &
consequence
Advance on
multiple fronts
Make the first move
Co-opt antagonists
Remove rivals, if
possible
Make the vision
compelling
Make important
relationships
work-no matter what
Persist
Use the personal
touch
Don't draw
unnecessary fire
Barriers:
Believe world is
just place &
everything will work
out
Following socially
acceptable desires for
leaders to be truthful,
modest & self effacing
Choosing not to
actively seek power,
guarding themselves
from experiencing a
knock to their
self-esteem when they
fail
Pfeffer
Selling the vision:
1. Establish sense of urgency
2. Creating the guiding coalition
3. Developing a change vision
4. Communicating the change vision
5. Empowering broad based action
6. Generating short-term wins
7. Never letting up
8. Incorporating changes into the culture
Role of Finance Director
More than just head accountant
Heart of decision making
Generating innovative
ideas to solve problems
Have 'presence'
Public Engagement
A structured communication or
dialogue between govt, public &
other interested parties, to inform
specific policy development or
specific service implementation
More specific than regular stakeholder
engagement-more focussed on specific
policy/service development
Types:
Information giving
Information gathering
Consultation
Involvement
Partnership
Empowerment
Ballots, tenant management associations
Online forums
Citizen's juries, workshops
Online, public meetings, surgeries
Surveys, focus groups
Leaflets, websites, public meetings
Collaborative Leadership
Characteristics to support collaboration:
Change should be led by most senior people appropriate
Scale & complexity should be well scoped & maintained
Common ground should be identified, agreement on problems & outcomes
Time devoted to understanding perspectives & values of diff parties
Time & resource devoted to regular & effective communication
Clear & equitable governance arrangement put in place, with transparent
decision-making & communication about developments
Partnership working takes time & resources
Attributes of successful collab leaders:
Political & strategic awareness
Interpersonal skills
Knowledge of the process
The 8 I's that create successful We's
Individual excellence
Importance
Interdependence
Investment
Information
Integration
Institutionalisation
Integrity
Moss Kanter
3 requirements for competitive advantage
of collaboration to be achieved:
Alliances are living systems that evolve
Alliances should involve collaboration
rather than mere exchange
Alliances require a dense web of interpersonal connections
& internal infrastructures that enhance learning
Innovation & Thought Leadership
Leaders need to be aware of the culture, capability &
capacity to innovate & support accordingly
Cultural requirements for innovation:
Risk taking
Resources
Knowledge
Goals
Rewards
Tools
Relationships
Thought Leadership
An entity that is seen as having
creative & innovative ideas
Sustainability
Spectrum of pub sec
leadership on
sustainable development
At risk
Compliance led
Incremental
Strategic
9 step model for
achieving sustainable
development