INTERPRETIVISM AND SUICIDE

Description

A-Level A2 SOCIOLOGY (Crime and deviance: Suicide) Flashcards on INTERPRETIVISM AND SUICIDE , created by ashiana121 on 07/01/2016.
ashiana121
Flashcards by ashiana121, updated more than 1 year ago
ashiana121
Created by ashiana121 almost 9 years ago
47
0

Resource summary

Question Answer
Interpretivists focus on the __________ of suicide for those involved Meanings
Who's theory is "The social meanings of suicide" Douglas
Douglas is interested in the way _______ label deaths as suicides Coroners
On how many grounds does Douglas criticise Durkheims study of suicide? 2
What are these grounds? 1. The use of suicide statistics 2. Actors meanings and qualitative data
How does Douglas criticise Durkheims use of suicide statistics? The decision to classify as death as a suicide is made by the coroner This may explain why individuals with high level of integration have low suicide rates - family and friends may be unwilling to accept the death as suicide and cover it up Socially isolated individuals will have nobody to oppose the suicide verdict on their behalf
Douglas argues that intergration does not prevent suicide, it merely affects the ________ of a death being ______ and ________ as a suicide, rather than it actually being a suicide. Affects the LIKELIHOOD of a death being LABELLED and RECORDED as a suicde
For Douglas, suicide verdicts and the statistics based on them are the product of __________ and _________ between those involved (friends, coroner, relative, doctors, police, social worker) Product of NEGOTIATIONS and INTERACTIONS
Douglas also criticises actors meanings and qualitative data. What does this mean? Durkheim ignores the meaning of the act and assumes that suicide has a fixed meaning.
Douglas notes that meanings of suicide can _____ ________ _______ Vary between cultures
Motives and meanings must be understood within their own... Social and cultural context
How, according to Douglas, must be classify each death according to its actual meaning? Qualitative methods Case studies based on suicide notes. and diaries In-depth interview with friends and relatives
What does Douglas suggest the meaning for suicides in Western societies include? Escape Repentance Search for help/sympathy Self punishment Revenge
For Douglas, using qualitative data also overcomes the problems caused by _______ _______ Official statistics
Douglas argues that official statistics are what? Socially constructed
What is a criticism of Durkheims classification of suicides based on meanings? There is no evidence to suggest that sociologists are better than coroners at interpreting a dead persons meaning
Douglas is _____________ Inconsistent
How? Sometimes suggests official stats are the product of coroners opinions Other times he suggest we can discover the cause of suicide - how can we know it was a suicide if all we have is the coroner saying it was a suicide
Who's theory is "ethnomethodology and suicide?" Atkinson
What does ethnomethodology mean? Its a method of social analysis that explores how individuals use everyday conversation to construct a common view sense of the world
Ethnomethodology argues that social reality is.... Simply a social construct of its members
We create reality used ___________ knowledge Commonsense
Atkinson accepts Douglas' point that official statistics are merely the constructs or labels coroners give to death. What point does he reject? That using qualitative data allows us to get behind the labels to find the real meanings - from this we can discover the real rate of suicide
Why does Atkinson argue we can never know the real rate of suicide? We would have to know for sure what meanings the deceased gave for deaths which is impossible
Atkinson argues the only thing we can study is... How we as humans come to classify a death as suicide, accident etc
What does Atkinson then focus on? How coroners categorise deaths
What methods did he use to do so? Qualitative Conversations with coroners Observations of inquests Examination of court records
What did Atkinson conclude from this research? Coroners have a commonsense theory about the typical suicide
What does this include? What type of person commits suicide For what reasons someone commits suicide How someone commits suicide Where someone commits suicide
What are coroners more likely to do if a death fits their commonsense theory? Class it as a suicide
Atkinson argues that coroners commonsense theories lead them to see the following types of evidence as relevant: - Suicide note/threats prior to death - Mode of death - Location and circumstances - Life history
What is meant by the life history? E.g a disturbed childhood, history of mental health issues, difficult social/personal situation (divorce, bereavement, social isolation) or bankruptcy are seen as classic causes of suicide
What does Atkinson conclude? Coroners are make a verdict by analysing cases using assumptions about what constitutes a typical suicide
Why does this cause problems for Durkheims theory? All statistics are doing are spelling out the coroners theory about suicide Taking the stats at face value is echoing the coroners commonsense theory, rather than discovering the cause of suicide
Give the name of one person who criticises Atkinsons ethnomethodology theory Structuralist Barry Hindess
What does Barry Hindess call Atkinsons theory? Self-defeating
Why does he say this? The coroners interpretations can be turned back on him - if we have only interpretations and no objective truth then ethnomethodologists accounts are no more than interpretations and there is no good reason to accept them
However, most ethnomethodologists accept this, unlike who? Positivists, who believe that their scientific and objective view of social reality is superior to those of the people (such as the coroners) they study
Who takes a realist approach went explaining and studying suicide? Taylor
What does he say about suicide statistics? They cannot be taken as valid
What did Taylor study? People who died by being hit by London tube trains
What did he find out? Half the cases reached the verdict of a suicide even though there was no conclusive evidence of suicidal intent
Taylor found that coroners saw factors such as what to increase the likelihood of a suicide verdict? A history of mental illness
How is Taylor's realist approach similar to the positivist approach? Taylor believes we can explain suicide and discover real patterns and causes
How does Taylor's approach differ from the positivist approach? He does not believe we can rely on suicide statistics
What does his realist approach aim to do? Reveal underlying structures and causes, which although not directly observable, can explain the observable evidence
What does he use to discover the underlying structures of meaning that cause suicide? Case studies
What does Taylor note about people who attempt suicide? They are not all sure their actions will kill them They are not all aiming to die - some are communicating with others
What does Taylor argue we need to study to adopt a broader definition of suicide? Both successful and unsuccessful attempts
What is an example of this definition? Any deliberate act of self-damage or potential self-damage where the individual cannot be sure of survival
In which situations does Taylor suggest a person is most likely to attempt suicide? Where there is TOTAL certainty or TOTAL uncertainty - either about themselves or others
How many types of suicide does Taylor identify? 4
What are the names of these 4 types? Submissive Thanatation Sacrifice Appeal
What does ectopic mean? Self-directed, the individual is psychologically detached from others An ectopic suicide is a private, self contained act
Which, of the 4 types of suicide identified by Taylor, are ectopic? Submissive & thanatation
Submissive suicides, where the person is... CERTAIN about themselves e.g - they know they have no reason to go on - they know they want to die, so suicide attempt is serious
Thanatation suicides, where the person is.. UNCERTAIN about themselves e.g - uncertain about what others think of them - attempt involves risk taking (they may/may not survive)
What does symphysic mean? Other directed Individual has overwhelming attachment to another person/people They feel the other(s) give them a reason for living A way of communicating with others
Sacrifice suicide, where the person is... CERTAIN about others e.g - betrayal/affair, other has done something that makes it impossible for individual to keep living - serious attempt
Appeal suicide, where the person is... UNCERTAIN about others e.g - they have doubts about their importance to others - communicating to change behaviour/opinion of other(s) - combination of wishing to die and wishing things to get better - risk taking
Taylors theory is based on ___________ of the actors meanings Interpretations
Why may individual cases be difficult to categorise? They may contain a number of motives
The London tube train study may be argued to be what? Too small to be representative of suicides in general
Unlike Durkheim, Taylor has not connected the 4 types of suicide to ____ _____ _______ Wider social structures
What are some similarities between the two (positivist Durkheim and interpretivist Taylor) theories of suicide? - Taylors uncertainty and certainty are parallel of Durkheims anomie and fatalism - Taylors ectopic and symphysic suicides are parallel to Durkheims egoistic and altruistic suicides
Show full summary Hide full summary

Similar

POSITIVISM AND SUICIDE
ashiana121
Functionalist Theory of Crime
A M
Realist Theories
A M
Control, Punishment & Victims
A M
Ethnicity, Crime & Justice
A M
Sociology: Crime and Deviance Flash cards
Beth Morley
Sociology - Crime and Deviance - Feminists
josaul1996
The Weimar Republic, 1919-1929
shann.w
Globalisation Case Studies
annie
Random German A-level Vocab
Libby Shaw
The Functionalist perspective on education
Phoebe Fletcher