The purpose of any licensing negotiations is for both sides to identify clearly what each wants from the
commercial arrangement they intend entering into.
THE TEAM
It is unwise to negotiate on your own, as points and issues may arise
that you are either unsure of or misinterpret.
Decide on who will lead the negotiations and outline
the process the team should follow in accepting or
rejecting proposals during the negotiation.
It is best to appoint a small team
NEGOTIATING
The process begins with discussion on the main
points that must be agreed and usually extends
over a period of time
May need to meet in person at some point in between, if discussions
become too complex toresolve certain issues on the phone.
It is important to avoid beginning negotiations with the exchange of a template
licence agreement as the initial draft document.
The Agreement reflect all the essentials of
the business transaction that both parties
seek agreement on
The negotiations shouldfocus on one item at a
time until agreement is reached
The contract must fulfil three essential elements. There must be: Terms of
exchange specified for the bargain; Something of value exchanged; and
Mutual exchange.
Licence Fee (also referred to as ‘lump sum’,
‘down payment’ or ‘upfront fee’)
Is a payment that,typically, is separate to
royalty payments.
licence fee is usually a set fee which all
licensees pay
An be agreed in a number
of alternative ways
*Cost of patents to date (or a percentage of these)
or cost of research to date (or a percentage of
this);A once-off non-refundable fee;among others.
The licence fee is intended to reflect a number of considerations:
Payment as a security or sign of intention that the licensee is
committed to commercialising the technology;A payment
towards a portion of the expenditures already committed by the
licensor.
Royalties
They are based usually on a unit, a volume
or a weight of sale – the ‘royalty base’. As
seen in , the ‘25% rule’ Chapter 16
approach is used frequently for the
negotiation of a royalty.
This necessitates an appreciation of the
operating costs, the likely sales price and the net
margin for the product from the technology
being licensed
Setting the Royalty Rate
In setting the royalty, consideration must be given to the
end-use or application of the product or technology.
Minimum Royalty
A minimum royalty can
be based on this market
forecast.
A minimum royalty may be appropriate in a
situation where the technology is at the
pre-market
It also ensures that the licensee will
do what is necessary to take it to
market as early as he can, so that
the minimum royalty is covered by
sales revenues as soon as possible.
Resetting Minimum
Royalties
In the event that the minimum royalty is not achieved,
partners usually build some scope into the licence
agreement for renegotiation of the minimum royalty on
reasonable terms,
HEADS OF AGREEMENT
Before any exchange of agreement templates begins, it is
essential that a ‘Heads of Agreement’
The key elements that should be discussed between the
parties to establish the main points of the agreement
It is important to be brief and specific on the points and to
avoid the temptation to express them in legal formulations.