size of army, soldiers quantity, experience, training
tactics & strategy
level of civilian support
propaganda
possession of key geographical areas
money & collection of taxes
Differences between the Sides
both sides = strengths & weakness - outcome not inevitable
Royalist strengths
immediate money
strong cavalry
experienced Prince Rupert (leader)
Royalist weaknesses
controlled poor areas of country
shortage of weapons more serious for them
Parliamentary strengths
controlled London & ports (collect customs duties)
controlled navy (prevent help from abroad)
Parliamentary weaknesses
immediate shortage of money -
take time to improve situation
C needed quick war - over before money
run out (less taxes than P)
P - better long-tern financial position = longer war (easier to collect taxes & from richer areas)
Early Stages of the War
Battle of Edgehill, 23rd Oct 1642
battle = draw (both sides claimed win)
1500 men died - shock of English killing English = negotiations reopened
after battle, C set up headquarters in Oxford
peace talks arranged but fighting intensified - both sides gain stronger position
'Battle' of Turnham Green, 13th Nov 1642
Prince R & 10,000 troops face Earl of Essex &20,000 Londoners = R retreated
revealed how important London was - large no. soldiers raised quickly
marked end of fighting season - travelling in winter = difficult
time of resting, planning & conducting peace talks
Winter of 1642-1643
peace talks opened in Oxford in Dec; abandoned April
P's demands = abolition of bishops, P approval of ministers, control of army & punishment of "evil councillors"
neither side had won so neither had motive for compromise
military preparations
Royalist Triple Advance = plan fro C main armies (N. S-W & C) to converge on London & force P surrender
P established Eastern Association (merged 5 armies) under Earl of Manchester: each army agreed to help if others attacked - attempt to overcome localism
Feb 1643; P introduced Weekly Assessment where taxes collected by County Committees (gentry) - later made monthly due to lack of resources
Royalist Successes
Early Royalist Successes
N. army captured Yorkshire & Lincolnshire, spring 1643 - E. Anglia next = provided food for P
capturing enemy land = one side gained & other lost tax, recruits, weapons & food
W. army captures Devon, Somerset & Dorset; 26th July = Bristol (2nd biggest port) captured
Parliament's Reaction
arguments between
Peace Party: moderates - wanted satisfactory negotiated peace (inc. Earl of Essex & Manchester - controlled army)
War Party: radicals - wanted military defeat of enemy (inc. Cromwell)
War P blamed Peace P for P failures
Pym persuaded MPs to pass financial measures
sequestrations of Royalist land
forced loan
excise (duty on alcohol & tobacco) = v. effective but unpopular esp. as many in lower classes drank beer rather than water
Royalist Failures
by late summer 1643 R armies in retreat
N. army worried about P stronghold @ Hull
W. army worried about Plymouth
C. army worried about Gloucester
example how localism held R back
these P strongholds = all ports - supplied by navy, which controlled by P
Alliances, Sept 1643
The Solemn League and Convent, 7th Sept 1643
P allied with the Scots
Scots sent army of 20,000 men
Scots wanted Presbyterian church in Eng - but English Presbyterian MPs wanted own church
Scot military expenses to be paid by Eng after war
The Cessation, 14th Sept 1643
C signed secret agreement with Irish rebels - secrecy led to rumours
Irish Rebellion to be suspended for 1yr
Irish rebels granted £30,000 to C - preferred C with Catholic sympathies
English troops in Ireland could return home
Death of Pym, Dec 1643
died of cancer
motives = protect traditional constitution & Protestant church - willing to use increasingly radical methods
Achievements = reforms of 1641, kept MPs united in early stages, laid foundations for P victory
Failures = radical methods lost support in 1641-2, country being torn apart by 1643
both sides short of money
throughout = resorted to: -
looting - seizure of goods -
free quarter
by late summer 1643 - apparent war not be quick - P began negotiating with Scots
The Year the Royalists Lost the War
Events, Jan - July 1644
Jan: 20,000 strong Scot army invaded N. Eng - threatened C N. army & R troops from Ireland captured in Cheshire
April: C's N. army besieged @ York by 3 armies ( Scot, P's Yorkshire & Eastern Association)
June: Prince R sent to relieve siege with 14,000 men
Battle of Marston Moor, 2nd July 1644
turning point?
P's forces ,arched to stop Prince R: assembled @ Marston Moor
Prince R got past them & rescued R - determined to fight P & told tired, starving soldiers it was C's orders
18,000 R vs 23,000 P
Cromwell's' cavalry charged, taking R by surprise - with help from Scots = 1st breakthrough & Rs fled
on other side: R seemed to be winning but couldn't control men - went for baggage train = surrounded and fought to death (finished @ 9:30pm)
Cromwell believed victory = God on their side
Consequences of Battle
1000 R dead, 15000 captured, N. army destroyed
Rupert escaped with several 100 soldiers
P lost 300 soldiers
2 weeks later: York surrendered to P who now took over N Eng - C lost lot of resources
brought victory in reach for P
Cromwell = national figure for command of cavalry
first decisive victory
P thought could quickly win war now
BUT
P did not follow up victory: Scot returned to border & no other part in war (fighting in Scot), Cromwell ordered back to E. Anglia, Fairfax stayed in York
localism prevented capitalising gains
despite C losses & lack of resources: P lost big battle in Cornwall (Sept), P
failed to defeat small R army @ Newbury (Oct), by end of 1644looked like
neither could win quickly, many MPs angry & blamed Earl of Essex &
Manchester
War Party wanted new leaders & national army to avoid localism
@ Council of War meeting: quarrel between Cromwell & Manchester
national army = too radical for some
peace talks opened in winter - the Uxbridge negotiations
Jan 1645: Laud put on trial = attempt to reunite MPs
How the War Ended
Uxbridge Negotiations, Jan - Feb 1645
peace talks failed & Peace party suffered
Parliament's terms
abolition of bishops
P approval of ministers
P control of army
punishment of 57 Royalists
King's attitude
want Anglican church
protect royal prerogative
valued supporters loyalty
New Model Army, Feb 1645
created by ordinance
national army of 22,000 men centrally controlled & paid
free from localism = could be sent anywhere in country
commander = Fairfax with Cromwell as cavalry commander
Self-Denying Ordinance, April 1645
all MPs with military commands had to resign them in 40days: Essex & Manchester resigned, Cromwell reappointed
Battle of Naseby, June 1645
NMA of 14,000 men
R army of 7500 men
Cromwell's repeated charges, discipline of NMA & advantage of numbers = R defeated
1000 R killed, 5,000 captured
R cannon, baggage train & writing carriage (with correspondence with Irish) captured
200 P's killed
R C. army detroyed
victory followed up: Battle of Longport, Somerset in July 1645 (S-W army destroyed)
11th Sept: Bristol recaptured, Rupert fled abroad
End of Civil War, Sept 1645 - May 1646
Sept 1645: Scot Royalists defeated
Clubmen Movement: southern county farmers armed themselves to stop armies entering (in Dorset, supported by 20,000)
April1646: Charles left Oxford in disguise
5th May: Charles surrendered to Scot army @ Newark, Nottinghamshire