Basic freedoms and Human Rights

Annotations:

• Things you are allowed to do

1. source of freedoms
   1. statutes

      Annotations:

      • Parliamentary laws
      1. magna carta 1215

         Annotations:

         • all people are equal under the law -  people cannot be imprisoned without evidence against them "habeus corpus"
      2. Bill of rights 1689

         Annotations:

         • Freedom of speech in parliament.  The monarch cannot interfere in the democratic process 
      3. Human Rights Act 1998

         Annotations:

         • incorporates the ECHR into UK law
   2. common law

      Annotations:

      • case law  made by judges
      1. Entick v Carrington (1765)

         Annotations:

         • Police cannot enter your property without proper permission or authority  
      2. Bushells case (1670)

         Annotations:

         • Right to a fair trial - judge cannot influence the decision of a jury
   3. EU
      1. ECHR

         Annotations:

         • European convention on human rights
2. What are the freedoms?
   1. freedom of expression

      Annotations:

      • Freedom of speech Freedom of the press and media important because it allows people to know what he government is doing allows people to be educated
   2. Freedom of the person

      Annotations:

      • limits unlawful stop and search limits arrest protects from slavery limits time in detention before charge important to protect people from an oppressive police force. 
   3. Freedom of association

      Annotations:

      • Free to hold peaceful meetings and demonstrations Join trade unions allows people to form groups to fight oppression and exploitation enables people to protest about issues like war or environmental issues 
   4. Freedom of thought and religion

      Annotations:

      • protects right to hold a religion or other views - veganism, atheism, pacifism.   important to allow a diverse society Protects right to observe religious rules - holy days, religious clothing 
   5. Freedom of information

      Annotations:

      • allows people ACCESS to information held about them and about the actions of public bodies Limits the recording and interception of messages  important because people can know if someone holds records about them, challenge them if they are wrong   allows people some privacy   
3. Limits to our freedoms

   Annotations:

   • Freedoms are not absolute.    They must be balanced betweent the needs of conflicting groups and people  
   1. freedom of expression
      1. Limited to protect national security

         Annotations:

         • official secrets act  prevents officials revealing security information 
      2. to protect health and morals

         Annotations:

         • restrictions on 'adult material' on television.  banning of extreme material
      3. prevent racial hatred

         Annotations:

         • speech which will incite racial hatred can be unlawful
   2. freedom of the person
      1. to enable police to investigate crime

         Annotations:

         • some stop and search and arrest is proportionate and necessary to protect society
      2. to prevent harm to individuals

         Annotations:

         • detention under the Mental Health Act for people's safety is sometimes necessary
   3. freedom of associoation
      1. limited to maintain order

         Annotations:

         • large demonstrations and marches should be properly authorised and managed to protect the safety of all
      2. to prevent terrorism

         Annotations:

         • membership of a terrorist group can be illegal - Al Qaida.   protects society by interfering with the organisational ability of the groups 

Annotations:

• things you are entitled to

1. Sources of Human Rights
   1. United Nations
      1. Universal Declaration 1948

         Annotations:

         • After the 2nd world war many nations of the world developed a document of things Humans ought to be entitled to. Just a wish list - no legal backing  
         1. no legal enforcement
   2. EU
      1. Convention on Human Rights

         Annotations:

         • a comprehensive list of "articles" the rights we can expect 
         1. Citizens of Europe can enforce these

            Annotations:

            • European Court of Human Rights can uphold these if member-states infringe the rights of their citizens
            1. European Court of Human Rights
   3. Parliament
      1. Human Rights Act 1998
         1. Allows UK courts to uphold rights from the ECHR
         2. all new laws must be compatible with ECHR
         3. evaluation
            1. positive

               Annotations:

               • allows UK citizens to assert rights in national courts- faster than European Courts allows British judges to have a role in shaping views about human rights.   Guides parliament to check new laws to make sure they are compatible with human rights 
            2. negative

               Annotations:

               • criticised as some say it is abused by people claiming rights to avoid normal process.  It is thought it may cause more legal claims and expense for legal aid system undermines the idea of parliamentary supremacy - judges can question parliamentary law 
   4. History

      Annotations:

      • based on ideas of freedom from ancient Greece , Romans Magna Carta and the French revolutionaries. 
2. Key human rights
   1. right to life

      Annotations:

      • issues: abortion turning off life support - coma euthanasia - Tony Nicklinson case in supreme court recently death penalty
   2. right to an education

      Annotations:

      • how to deliver this right to pupils excluded from school
   3. right to respect for private family life

      Annotations:

      • issues to consider Surveillance, CCTV  Internet and mobile phone data being stored and used to monitor for terrorism and other crime (paedophiles) should foreign criminals who have a family in the UK be deported? balancing the punishment of individuals with the rights of the family   
   4. right to religious freedom

      Annotations:

      • should employers have to respect all requests for time off on faith days?  should Christians be able to express their faith with a cross or a chastity ring (when these things are otherwise forbidden by a uniform policy)?
   5. liberty and security

      Annotations:

      • balancing the police need to investigate crime (stop and search, arrest) with the rights of the individual.  are police actions proportionate? 
   6. right to free expression

      Annotations:

      • limited by Official secrets act.  should there be protection of 'whistle blowers' such as the Americans Edward Snowden and Bradley Manning who revealed US government secrets about surveillance and military wrong-doing.      
   7. right to a fair trial

      Annotations:

      • includes tight to be presumed innocent   consider secret trials - government proposes to hold some terrorism trials without a jury or public gallery.  longer period without charge in terrorism cases (14 days)   Should children be tried in adult courts? could they get a fair trial?  
   8. freedom from torture and degrading treatment

      Annotations:

      • consider: corporal punishment (smacking) of children. Deporting people to countries where they may face torture (Abu Hamza case)  With-holding basic  benefits from assylum seekers, who cannot legally work.  

Annotations:

• most rights are not ABSOLUTE.  they have to balanced with needs of society and the rights of others

1. right to freedom from torture
2. right to life

   Annotations:

   • An absolute right - except... where you are killed to preserve the life of another  - it is necessary.  Self defence: also Jody and Mary - conjoined twins case