"civilized" American law vs. "uncivilized" Italian tradition
When the American justice system is
incapable of bringing the characters the kind
of justice they think they deserve,
everything goes haywire.
They resort to
their unspoken
codes of their
Italian roots.
This results in
stuff like bloody
revenge and
duels in the
streets.
The Red Hook community knows that
the law does not provide justice.
Eddie and Marco want justice but Alfieri warns that the
law cannot help.
If he obeys the law, he
lives.
Alfieri establishes
importance of Justice and
the Law in his opening
speech
"In Sicily, from where their
fathers came, the law has
not been a friendly idea since
the Greeks were beaten.."
Vinny Bolzano: Obeying
the law yet doing
something unjust - (Foreshadow)
they grabbed him in the kitchen and pulled him
down the stairs...And they spit on him in the street,
his own father and his brothers. The whole
neighbourhood was crying."
"a guy do a thing like that? How's he gonna
show his face?"
Eddie is warned by Alfieri to allow
C & Rs wedding - suggests his
feelings for C are "unnatural".
"When the law is wrong it's because it's
unnatural, but in this case it is natural and a
river will drown you if you buck it now."
Eddie ironically snitches on M & R to immigration Bureau
- he has no fixed principle of justice, his feelings dictate
what he believes to be 'just'.
Betrayal of Family and Community - Like Vinny
Morally and legally you have no rights, you
cannot stop it; she is a free agent.
Alfieri tries to make Marco realise
who is the real 'judge' of events - God.