The taille and vintigeme
were only paid by the third
estate.
Tax was collected by tax farming in which only quotas had to be met,
meaning that the money collected from taxes could'nt cover France's
expenditure.
Venal officials bought their
positon meaning corrupt officials
couldn't be removed.
French society
First Estate
Unpopular due to; plurality and
absenteeism (bishops having more than
one diocese), tithes (making the church
the single largest land owner in France,
with 10 per cent of land), tax
exemption (with an income of around
100 million livre), power over people
(causing resistance to new ideas).
Second Estate
Unpopular due to privledge; tried
in special courts, exempt from
military service, the gabelle and
corvee.
Third Estate
Bourgeosie had no political rule under
absolutism and the burden of taxation largely
fell on the Third Estate.
(Estates of
Realm)
Enlightenement
Voltaire
Felt the power of the church needed to be
limited as highlighted in On Toleration
Rousseau
Argued in the 'Social Contract' that
legitimate government should be based
upon popular sovereignty.
Montesquieu
Wanted the separation of legislative and
executive power with checks and
balances. De L'Espirit de Lois.
These thinkers rejected
hierarchical government and
religious superstition, which
was key to the Ancien regime.
Short Term Factors
Foreign Policy
Seven Year War lost in 1763,
Guadelope and Martinque countries
with sugar lost.
The American War of Independence-
(1776-1783), 1066 million livre spent, in the
short term worsening the already weak
financial situation of the crown.
Ideas such as liberty and democracy spread.
Financial Crisis
On 20th August 1786- nearing
bankruptcy, 112 million livre
deficit in 1786.
Increased in 1788 to 126 million livre, anticipated that for
1780, interest payments of the deficit would amount to 62
per cent of receipts.
Attempts at Reform
1. Turgot encouraged free circulation
of grain, resulting in the Flour War.
2. Introduced a General Land Tax, to be paid
by all, his proposals were largely referred to
as the Six Edicts. These were however
opposed by the rival minsters and the PP and
he was fired.
3. Necker helped facilitate loans with the 1781,
Compte Rendu, showing a surplus of revenue as
he didn’t mention the 200 million livre being
spent on warfare, this had long term effects.
4. Calonne raised over 400 million livres initially
however loans dried up in 1786, he proposed
General Land tax and an abolition of temporary
taxes such as the vingtieme.
5. The Paris Parlement refused to register the
new loans, due to the Compte Rendu's false
picture of French Finances. Then call the
Assembly of Notables who refuse.
6. Calonne is fired. Brienne waterer down
Calonnes reforms, putting forward his new
ideas to the Paris Parlement.
7. They refused and Louis exiled them in
August 1787, however as the financial
situation came dire he needed to bring
them back.
8. Louis passed the reforms by a lit de justice, causing the
Revolt of the Notables and the Fundamental Laws of the
Kingdom.
Revolt of Notables
ST: Actions by Brienne and Calonne to introduce the
General Land Tax largely affected the first two Estates,
with the nobility claiming that such a large change
must be put forward to the Estates General.
LT- Philosphe ideas, King was acting tyrannically in
trying to force through change, felt the May Edicts
were an example of ministerial despotism, therefor
the parlement were acting to the will of the people.
ST- Unpopularity and apparent weakness of
Calonne, Brienne and King, meant that even
those who agreed with fair taxation were
suspicious of how it would be carried out,
furthermore the fact the King kept changing
his mind firing minsters did not help the
situation.
Economic Crisis
The economy was largely based on agriculture,
therefore the bad harvests in 1778-9, 1781-2,1785-6
had a large impact.
In 1788-9 bread was 88 % of a
labourer's wage.
Textile production fell by 50% in 1789, largely affecting
women in rural areas .
Ordinary people accused land-owners and tithe-owners of grain
hoarding.
Politicisation of the
Third Estate came out of
the economic crisis.