FACTORS LEADING TO (CATHOLIC) REFORMATION - The condition of the Catholic Church in the early C16th
Description
AS level History (Hackett) (1.1 Humanism & the Catholic Church c.1500) Mind Map on FACTORS LEADING TO (CATHOLIC) REFORMATION - The condition of the Catholic Church in the early C16th, created by dolce-n-banana on 30/01/2014.
FACTORS LEADING TO (CATHOLIC)
REFORMATION - The condition of the
Catholic Church in the early C16th
THE NEED FOR CHANGE
1500-Catholic Church
was the universal faith
Canon law touched the lives of
everyone
Pope claimed to be the first apostle St
Peter & representative of Christ on
earth
Traditional view of the early church;
abuses so widespread & deep & it failed
to carry out it's functions
ABUSE THEORY
CHALLENGED:
Church always has been criticised. There
have been worse periods of corruption
(scandal where there were several popes at a
time) but the Church has always been able to
adapt itself
Reformers not only attacked the
abuses - they attacked the
fundamental teachings
One of the abuses they targeted,
celibacy (remaining unmarried) - there
are no accurate & reliable statistics to
back it up
The things they complained about (ignorant
priests, idle (lazy) monks, methods of receiving
money) were not worse or as widespread as
they were 100 years ago. It shows that the
Church was capable of reforming itself.
RENAISSANCE POPES
Popes claimed their authority from
the promises Christ made to Peter -
Petrine Promises - They are St
Peters successors
C15th-16th -
Popes authority
was in decline
Growing anti-papal feeling
(Mainly in Germany)
FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES -Popes
were businessmen
Fees to collect Annates, First
Fruits, provide exemption from
some of the rules in Church,
benefice
Required administrators (costly)
Some states were
beginning to reduce the flow
of funds (England) & there
were increased costs
New ways had to be found
to raise money - unpopular
Simony (buying/selling church
jobs) & Pluralism (holding more
than one job)
E.G. Archbishop of
Salzburg was charged
10,000 guilden to
become an archbishop
Showed Pope as greedy
than caring for the needy
'The Church charged its
members for all its services-for
marriages, baptisms,
confessions & burials' - J.A.P.
Jones
PRESSURE ON POPE TO BE A
SECULAR RULER
Wordly power instead of
religious power
In control of papal states in central
Italy (He had to govern & defend
these areas)
1494 Italian wars began,
so the Pope became more
involved in worldly affairs
LEADERSHIP CRISIS
Some Popes claims to
spirtitual leadership was odd
as scandals occurred -
including in the papal court
(Alexander VI, Julius II, Leo X)
Visitors to Rome
(Erasmus/Luther) were shocked
to see luxury & a causal attitude
to practicing the Catholic faith
In Germany - anti papal
& growing sense of
nationalism ( because of
foreign papal interference
& increasing Church tax)
May have been exaggerated on the
scandalous lives of the papacy - the
public lapped it up by descriptions,
cartoons which spread because of the
printing press. These gained more
importance after 1517
Crisis of leadership did not always weaken the
peoples faith. It must also be remembered some
Popes tried to enforce reform - Previously, (last
200 years) European rulers had decreased the
papal authority, meaning it was hard for them to
enforce change
IGNORANCE OF THE CLERGY
HIGHER CLERGY
Bishops/archbishop tended to come from the nobility, so
when given their job, they came into it with the same
attitude as if they were still nobility (eating to excess,
wearing rich garments, large numbers of servants,
building grand houses)
IGNORANCE as they did not show a true example to the public
ABSENTEEISM (not living in your diocese) -
e.g. Archbishop of Sens only entered his
own cathedral once - his funeral
PLURALISM (holding more than one job)
NOT all ignorant - good level of
education, there are records to show
bishops who visited their parishes who
improved discipline & faults
Absenteeism could be
caused by the monarch
using them as
ministers/diplomats
Supply of high quality/educated
bishops were limited
MONASTERIES & CONVENTS
Spiritual decline
Records show that there was a lack of
discipline, ignorance of daily routine
prayer, inability to read, breaking vows
of celibacy, not living lives of poverty
cannot carry out
the rules of
monastic life
Admission to monasteries was too easy (no
education required)
Wealthy convent could receive
daughters of the noble class who were
unmarried. They could live comfortably
but have little interest/ignorance in
religious life
Some signs of reform; stricter
groups of monks created -
Franciscians (Spain) &
Augustians (Germany)
LOWER CLERGY
Parish priests/clergy
condemned for their
ignorance
Visitations to Italy show that
some could not read service
books or say basic prayers
Ignorance increasing as
bursaries were becoming
harder to access for the
poorer priests
Entry was so easy all you really
needed was basic education
Did not wear separate clerical clothes,
joined in activities of the parish church,
gamed/quarreled with their neighbour
Received tithes, fees from
marriages/burials/baptism. Sometimes
gained free labour
Church producing too
much priests
Poor, young,
unemployed, little
education - a
dangerous
combination that
could affect the
standards of the
Church
Celibacy (remaining
unmarried) hard to
enforce - easy to spot -
ideal for criticisms