Chapter 5: Economic Theory, Marxism,
and Material Culture
Needs Versus Desires: Traveling Light
and Arriving Heavy
objects/ possesions
brand
shopping
attachment to possessions
Marxist Theory & Alienation
economic & psychological theories
explain the role of capitalism in the
modern world
alienation: a separation or
estrangement of man's true nature
from the sense of self
Tenets
Annotations:
1. needs are not real but artificially imposed upon people by advertising that tries to convince that buying means happiness
2. people are alienated because the work is external (work = making money to live)
3. objects & artifacts are signifiers of the alienation & estrangement
Class Conflict
classes: bourgeoisie & proletariat
false consciousness doctrine
unequal distribution of goods
Role of Advertising
Advertising - the main engine of consumer culture
in capitalist societies. It is a merchandizing tool and
the industry. It gives objects their valuation (Henri
Lefebvre)
Immediate goal: to sell artifacts & products. Long-term goal: to turn people's
attention away from exploitation & justify the existence of a capitalist economic
system.
Thorsten Veblen and Conspicuous Consumption
Ultimate goal: an enhanced sense of self; to excel
neighbors to attain heightened self-evaluation.
Functional analysis - objects' function to
indicate & enhance status
Max Weber & Calvinist-Protestant Thought
worldly Protestant asceticism
Protestant ethics justifies consumption.
Divine Providence justifies the unequal distribution of wealth .
Georg Simmel on Fashion
clothing
new models of artifacts
women's fashion consciousness
Walter Benjamin & the Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction
the impact of mass production on objects
aura = authenticity
Authenticity & Postmodern Thought
Tenets
Annotations:
1. Overarching metaphysical systems of belief are not important any more.
2. no boundaries between elite & popular cultures and between original works of art & reproductions/ imitations. Authenticity is not important.
3. Contemporary American culture is postmodern with mixed styles.
John Berger on Objects & Adversitising
Publicity is about social relations, not objects
Definitions: artifacts & human
labor
Annotations:
Artifacts - objects showing human workmanship.
Human labor - labor that involves designing, manufacturing, transporting, advertising, and selling objects.