Brown and Harris (1978) found that women who suffer
chronic stress conditions e.g. being unemployed were more
likely to develop depression
Melchior et al (2007) carried out a survey over a
period of 1 year among 1000 people in a wide
range of occupations in New Zeland
found that 15% of those in high-stress jobs suffered a
first episode of clinical depression or anxiety during that
yearm compared with 8% in low-stress jobs
Stress and other disorders
after the Vietnam war ended in 1975 - the
mass incidence of psychiatric
symptoms among war veterans led to
the 'discovery' of post traumatic stress disorder
PTSD has been observed in war veterans and rape victims, as
well as the victims of chronic stress such as poverty and abuse
Peroetratuin Induced Traumatic Stress (PITS) (MacNair 2002) is a form of PTSD
caused by being an active participant in causing trauma (e.g. soliders - where it is
socially acceptable or expected for them to kill)
Rohlf and Bennet (2005) found that 1 in 10 workers, whose occupations required
euthanising animals, experienced moderate levels of PITS syndrome
Evidence for stress being linked to other
psychiatric conditions is less strong than Rohlf and Bennet
e.g. Stueve et al (1998) compared
the role of stressful life event in
causing depression, schizophrenia
and other disorders
found stressful events only associated with depression not with other disorders
evaluation
the diathesis-stress model
proposes that in order for a person to develop phychiatric
disorders they must possess a biological vulnerability to that
disorder (the diathesis)
an individuals vulnerablility is determined by genetic or early
biological factors (e.g. exposure to viral infections in the womb)
stress can have an impact on that vulnerablility, either triggering the onset of
the disorder or worsening its course
if the person is not capable of adapting to the stressful situation psychiatric symptoms will develop or worsen
it is frequently not possible to assess whether stressful events in the period before
diagnosis of a phychiatric disorder have causes the disorder or been a consequence
of the person's deteriorating state
although the relationship between stress and depression has
been demonstrated by some researchers, others (e.g. Rabkin
1993) claim that the effects are small, accounting for less than
10% of the variance observed