following obedience from an authority figure
BLIND OBEDIENCE: when people are hurt/you hurt people in obeying.
Agentic state
Annotations:
mental condition
independence and conscience suppressed
acts as an agent on behalf of an authority figure and defers the responsibility
Moral strain
Annotations:
consequences of doing something you know to be wrong
and going against conscience
eg. the fits and sweating from milgrams participants
Autonomous
Annotations:
Mental condition
individual thinking and acting independently in accordance with own freen will with fully active conscience
Evaluation
For
Annotations:
Milgram (63)
participants ordered to give electric shocks to a learner if they got the question worng. 65% went up to 450 v. IN AGENTIC STATE
Meeus and raaijmakers
agentic participants -- instead of physical violence was psychological - 15 increasingly distressing remarks
hofling (66)
nurses gave overdose when ordered to- authority figure- agentic state
Hofling
Milgram
meeus and raaijmakers
Applicaction
Annotations:
Nazis
authority figure= hitler
agentic= nazi soldiers (eichman)
autonomous= schindler
Abu Ghraib
agentic=soldiers
authority figure=senior officer
autonomous= joe darby.
Nazi
Abu Ghraib
Alternative
Annotations:
social power theory (french and raven 59)
different reasons= rewards, punishment avoidance and expert power
weakens theory
Idividual differences= why some obey and others don't= not explained