Zusammenfassung der Ressource
Natural Law
- Aquinas' Four Tiers of Law
- 1. Eternal Law
- God made and controls the universe and which only God knows
completely. We only know these as 'reflections'; only we have a
partialand approx understanding of laws which govern the universe
- 2. Devine Law
- The Bible - this reflects eternal law. Only be seen by
those who believe in God
- 3. Natural Law
- The theory that an eternal, absolute
moral law can be discovered by reason
- 4. Human Law
- Human laws are the customs and
practices of society
- Aquinas' Natural Law
- Aristotle
- Aristotle said that morality
should be based on reason not
emotions
- The telos
- Aquinas though that moral acts were
free acts aimed at achiveing an
immediate and ultimate end
- Primary and Secondary Precepts
- Five Primary Precepts
- 2. To live in an ordered society: a lawful
one where it is possible to follow all the
PP
- 3. To reproduce: to ensure that life continues as is God's
intention and as necessary for the continuation of
society
- 4. To learn: to teach people
about God and his laws and PP
- 5. To defend the innocent
- 1. To worship God: God is the source of eternal law, and
God has sent this law to humanity through divine and
human law
- Secondary Precepts
- Reason what would be
essential to get to the PP
- 'Do good, avoid evil'
- Precepts and Reason
- Casuistry
- Name given to the process of applying natural law
principles to specific situations. Done in a logical way to
have logical consequences
- Double Effect
- Refers to situations where there are intended out comes
and another significant but unintentional outcome.
- According to NL our intentions are improtant not the consequences.
- Four conditions we must meet:
- 1. We do not wish evil effects and make all
reasonable efforst to avoid them
- 2. The immediate effect in itself
should be good
- 3. The evil is not made a means to obtain the good
- 4. The good effect should be as
important, proportionsly at least, as
the evil effect
- Strengths and Weaknesses
- Strengths
- Having secondary precepts allows flexibility
- Most cultures follow the PP
- PP make NL more objective
- Gives us a telos
- DE allows a more liberal view
- Focuses on human potential
for flourishing
- Absolutist view of morality
- Combines faith and reason
- Appeals to human instinct
- Weaknesses
- Challengeable
- Modernity
- Individuals within a culture may not
follow the view
- Complex situations
- Money as a limiting factor
- Some cultures believe that women
shouldn't be educated
- Commits naturalistic fallacy
- Everything in nature is
good - cancer?
- Faiths wihtout a God