Classical: Child cries, food given (
unconditioned stimulus), child
experiences pleasure
(uncondtioned response),
caregiver associated with
good(conditioned stimulus) , child
attaches to caregiver.
Operant: Newborn baby feels
hungry/experiences discomfort, crying
causes discomfort for the caregiver
who then consoles child which is
positive reinforcement for child but
negative for parent as they have to keep
returning and parent attaches.
Evaluation
Evidence from lab
with Animals
However animal
behavouir may not
apply to human.
Reductionist as its too
simple of complex
human behaviour
Schaffer&Emerson: less
than 1/2 formed primary
attachment with caregiver.
Explored, very upset when mother
left&returned wanted comfort, quickly
calmed and played, Sensitive mothers.
Type A: Insecure-Avoidant (22%)
Ignored mother, few signs of stress, ignored
when returned, mother stranger similar, most
distressed. Ignorant mothers.
Type C: Insecure-Resistant (12%)
VERY distressed, not easily
consoled,sought comfort&rejected. Mother
angry/rejecting or over sensitive.
Evaluation
Useful tool for measuring
attachment
Reliable due to Warner proving the
type stays the same throughout life.
Used in some real life situations
Demand characteristics don't effect kids.
Isabella: she isn't
studying what she
said she was.
Ethical issues: Distress
Low Ev due to it being too
structered/artificial
Parent: Demand characteristics
Cultural variations
Van Ijzendoorn&Kroonenburg- Meta
Analysis. Type B most common, type A
more in western and type C in
Japan&Israel. Type B the 'norm' which
support innate process.
Fox- Supports bowlbys
monotropy( Isreali children
looked after my loads)
Takahashi- 60 middle class, B-68, A-32 C-0.
90% Studdies stopped. Imposed
etic=innapropiate to be used on the kids and
the sample was limited due to 1 class used.
Grossman&Grossman- German,
cultural bias- might look at
findings as wrong when they
may be norm for that country.
Tronick- African, one man
attachment, supports
monotropy.
Deprivation/Privation
Seperation
PDD model, protest, despair,
detachment. One long term effect is
seperation anxiety, shown by...
aggressive behaviour, great
demands,clingym detachement,
pyschomatic symptoms.
Privation-Never forming one
Czech Twins- cruely treated by
father/st'mother, discovered at 7, fearful,
fosterhome/hospital, well improved and
sorted out.
Genie- Found 13, severe
neglect/pysical restraint, young
appearance,never went back to
normal.