Abortion

Description

Beliefs in support or against abortion. Mainly quotes and views on; Sanctity of Life, Quality of Life and Personhood.
jessnrm98
Flashcards by jessnrm98, updated more than 1 year ago
jessnrm98
Created by jessnrm98 over 8 years ago
14
0

Resource summary

Question Answer
What is Abortion? The artificial termination of a foetus - before it can survive independently.
Quote the 1967 Act of Parliament on Abortion, and state the amendment of this act in 1991. Allows abortion on the ground that it can; a) Risk the life of the pregnant woman - mental, physical and emotional health inflicted on the mother or foetus, or any of her existing children. b) By the consent of two doctors. 1991 amendment: Reduced the time limit to 24 weeks - shows sign that foetus can survive independently.
Name one feminist supporter of abortion, and list any feminist claims to abortion. Germain Greer - active feminist in the 1960s. 1. Cut backstreet abortions 2. Unwanted babies that potentially are born into a life of poverty. 3. Ban of male domination on women during the rise of secular society.
Explain the Sanctity of Life? It is the belief, commonly held by the Christian Church. It holds that the life is sacred, and because God made us in his image, and that he is our Creator - life is sacred and can only be chosen to be taken by Him.
Quote Job 35:15 15 "Did not he who made me in the womb make them? Did not the same one form us both within our mothers?"
Explain Ensoulment. It is an old traditional Christian belief present in ancient writings which states the time when the physical body is infused with the soul: 40 days for males, 90 days for females. It is linked to the Sanctity of Life where it views human life sacred.
Quote Jeremiah 1:5 and state how it can be used against abortion. 5 "Before I formed you in the womb I knew you." This is an indication of the sanctity of life going against abortion - showing that God is the creator and that the will of taking another life only rests upon God alone.
Quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church against abortion. Listed as 2270 Abortion, the Catholic Church recognises human life as sacred; "Human life must be respected from the moment of conception." "From his existence, a human being must be recognised as having the rights of the person." (Same can be used for Personhood).
Church of England views on Abortion? Despite stating that they also uphold the sanctity of life, they also recognise the certain circumstances; "...but the right of the innocent to life surely admits few exceptions indeed. Circumstances exist... in some circumstances the foetus could be regarded as the aggressor on the mother."
Explain the three views on the question "When does Life Begin?" Some believe life begins at conception, recognising that the embryo itself must be regarded as a potential human person - or in this case the sanctity of life retaining its protection. During pregnancy: Others have the view of Ensoulment but most significantly the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act state the embryo is regarded as a foetus in 14 days of conception. This is to mainly allow the legal aspect to scientific research. After Birth:
State John Locke's (1632 - 1704) view on Personhood, and how it can be used in support of abortion. Recognises humans are sentient; 1. Capable of free will 2. Individuality 3. Social Nature 4. Principle of Reciprocity (give/take in social manner) However, a foetus protected in the womb do not retain these values, but only hold the potentiality of becoming a human. In this case, the fact that it is only a "potential" human and not already recognised as one, personhood allows abortion.
State some criticisms against John Locke's view against personhood. It excludes people who are in a persistent vegetative state, animals or those who have severe disabilities.
State Michael Tooley's Principle of Moral Equivalence. It describes how foetuses should not be considered as a person, justifying abortion. If we do the same things to animals, then can't we do it foetus as well? (Foetus does not have recognisable human features - physically or mentally).
State key concepts in John Locke's view on Liberal Body Ownership and its support to abortion. Individual ownership of our body rejects personhood: a) Woman considering abortion has a right to the use of her body. b) Foetus being part of the body is subject to the ownership of the woman. c) Considering abortion means to improve a situation.
What is the Quality of Life argument? The quality life assesses the value of the foetus life, and that human life is not inherently valuable but what kind of life it is.
Consider some general beliefs in in the Quality of Life argument and criticism against these beliefs. Humans possess a sense of "self" to be considered a human; i) Must be conceived humans ii) Human genetic structure iii) To look like a human iv) must have soul v) viability to survive vi) potentiality of holding a future How do we really consider the development of a foetus having these qualities to become human?
Criticise Mary Anne's Warren criteria for personhood. We cannot really determine whether foetuses do not really develop the ability of reasoning. But most importantly, it excludes those who have severe mental disabilities, in a PVS... etc...
What is the main idea behind Judith Jarvis Thompson's Analogy? The Unconscious Violinist Analogy explains the fact that we are not "obligated" in certain circumstances (e.g rape, unwanted pregnancies) to protect the life of the innocent.
Show full summary Hide full summary

Similar

Environmental Ethics
Jason Edwards-Suarez
Computing Hardware - CPU and Memory
ollietablet123
Biology B1.1 - Genes
raffia.khalid99
Biology B1.3
raffia.khalid99
A2 Organic Chemistry - Reactions
yannycollins
GCSE Biology B2 (OCR)
Usman Rauf
Unit 1 flashcards
C R
Cell Structure
megan.radcliffe16
Exchange surfaces and breathing
megan.radcliffe16
AS Chemistry - Enthalpy Changes
Sarah H-V
C1 Quiz
Leah Firmstone