Recognises the
experience of the
patient so we can
view mental
disorder from
their point of view
For some e.g.
psychopaths have a high
level of function but
would still be considered
abnormal by a
psychiatrist. This
definition does not apply
to all
Easy to judge because
we can list behaviours
and therefore indicate
abnormality
Individuals may feel
content in situation,
others are
uncomfortable. WHO
JUDGES?
Judged on ability to go about everyday life
For example
eating or
washing
regularly
Deviation from
social norms
Departing or diverging from
standard behaviour in a given
society
isolates mentally ill
Evaluation
It is straightforward to
indicate individuals that
have a mental health
problem so they can
receive treatment. So by
this, it will benefit the
individual so they are
offered treatment and
society.
Does not take into account
the context e.g.wearing a
bikini on a beach is
acceptable but not at a social
event.
Allows change as society evolves e.g.
homosexuality used to be classified
as a mental disorder on the DSM.
Some believe that because it
allows change it just excludes
nonconformists from society.
Therefore not reliable
Based on what disturbs others so it is culture relative
Based on dominant
group which is white
middle class
Deviation from ideal
mental health
Marie Jahoda
composes of 6 things
Self-actualisation (personal growth)
Self attitudes
Integration
Being able to
cope in stressful
situations
Autonomy
Being independant
Accurate perception of reality
Mastery of environment
ability to love, function at
work and adjust to new
situations
An absence of
criteria indicates
abnormality and
possibly a mental
disorder
Evaluation
Difficult to measure
According to this crate
many of us will be
abnormal so it is unrealistic
Suggests mental health is the same as
physical health, even though it's more
complicated than that. And this crate
suggests that they are easy to detect
but mental health issues are based on
life experience.
Offers an alternative
approach towards mental,
health in a more positive
manner.
Indicates what characteristics are desirable or not
Statistical Infrequency
Mean, Mode
and median
Behaviour found in individuals
which is rare is considered
abnormal
Evaluation
Difficult to determine when
there is a cut-off point as to
when something is
abnormal or normal. Eg.
difficulty sleeping in
depression
It is objective as it is
statistical information to
reach a conclusion on
someones mental health
Does not indicate what
characteristics are
desirable or not e.g. high
IQ, as its rare it is
considered as statistically
infrequent
DSM is based in west where
dominate population is white
middle class, so therefore is not
applicable in other cultures and
regions