Zusammenfassung der Ressource
1. Leadership in the Public Services
- Definition of Leadership
- Leadership is a process whereby
intentional influence is exerted by 1
person (or a group) over other people
to structure the activities and
relationships in a group or organisation
- Management vs Leadership
- Leadership one aspect of Management
- Mintzberg
- Interpersonal skills:
- Figurehead
- Leadership
- Liaison
- Information skills:
- Monitor
- Disseminator
- Spokesperson
- Decisional roles:
- Entrepreneur
- Disturbance handler
- Resource allocator
- Negotiator
- Management/Leadership differences:
- Manager:
- administers
- maintains
- systems & structures
- relies on control
- bottom line
- does things right
- Leader:
- innovates
- develops
- focus on people
- inspires trust
- eye on the horizon
- does the right things
- Hollingsworth
- Subordinate goals
- Structure
- Strategy
- System
- Skills
- Staff
- Style
- McKinsey Seven S Framework
- LEADERSHIP RELY ON:
- MANAGEMENT RELY ON:
- Watson
- Bases of Power:
- Reward Power
Anmerkungen:
- based on the subordinate's perception that the leader has the ability to control rewards that the followers are looking for
- Coercive Power
Anmerkungen:
- Based on fear & the subordinate's perception that the leader has the ability to punish or to cause an unpleasant experience for those who do not comply
- Referent Power
Anmerkungen:
- Based on the subordinate's identification with the leader
- Expert Power
Anmerkungen:
- Based on the subordinate having the perception that the leader is someone who has access to information & relevant power
- Legitimate Power
Anmerkungen:
- Based on authority and not on personal power
- French & Duncan
- Leadership traits:
- Strong drive for responsibility
- Focus on task completion
- Vigour and persistence in the pursuit of goals
- Venturesomeness & originality in problem solving
- Drive to exercise initiative in social settings
- Self confidence
- Sense of personal identity
- Willingness to accept consequences of
decisions and actions
- Readiness to absorb interpersonal stress
- Willingness to tolerate frustration & delay
- Ability to influence behaviour of others
- Capacity to structure social
systems to the purpose at hand
- Stogdill
- Better than average on:
- Ability
- Sociability
- Motivation
- Leadership Style &
Behaviour Theory
- Management &
Leadership style is
influenced by the
persons' assumptions
about human nature
- McGregor's Theory X/Y
- Theory X:
- Negative view on human nature
- Worker not motivated to work,
doesn't want to be there
- Coercion & control the only way
to get people to work hard
- Theory Y:
- Positive view on human nature
- Workers will actively seek responsibility
- Leadership style one of
encouragement & facilitation,
encouraging creativity & innovation
- Likert
- Production centred
- Leader pays close
attention to work of
subordinates
- Employee centred
- Leader is interested in developing
cohesive working groups & ensuring
that employees are satisfied
- LBDQ
Anmerkungen:
- Leadership Behaviour Description Questionnaire
- Structure Behaviour
- Formal lines of communication & control, leader
determines how tasks are performed
- Consideration Behaviour
- Leaders shows concern for their subordinates,
warm supportive climate
- Blake
- Contingency Theory
- No single leadership style that is correct for every
situation, for every leader, in all circumstances
- Fielder
- Least-preferred co-worker
scale to identify style of leader
- High score=people oriented
- Low score=task oriented
- Proposed that leader has to adapt style to suit situation, and success
of leader was related to knowledge of the maturity level of employees
- 4 levels of maturity:
- Unable and unwilling
- Unable and willing
- Able and willing
- Able and unwilling
- Hershey & Blanchard
- Leadership & management intervention is proposed to be on a
continuum dependent upon skills, expertise & experience of the group
- Tannenbaum & Schmidt
- Closer supervision for subordinates who are inexperienced or lacking in skills at first
- Close attention & supervision reduces over time, once skills & experience have developed
- Leaders must balance the needs of the Task, Team &
Individual, & vary the amount of attention he pays to each o
these 3 areas according to the requirements of the situation
- Task element-setting clear objectives & expectations, &
managing processes required for people to follow
- Team element-ensuring communication & interactions
between team members are smooth, & that workload is
balanced across the team
- Individual element-considering the individual needs of
people & spending time & effort getting to know how
individuals are feeling
- Transformational vs Transactional Leadership
- Transformational
- To transform people & orgs in a literal sense,
changing them in heart & mind, enlarging
their vision & clarifying purpose
- Builds on need for meaning
- Preoccupied with purpose,
values, morals & ethics
- Transcends daily affiairs
- Long term goals without
compromising human values
- Focuses more on mission & strategy
- Releases human potential-identifies talent
- Designs & re-designs jobs to make
them challenging & meaningful
- Aligns internal structures & systems to
reinforce overarching values & goals
- Transactional
- 'Business as usual' where leaders gain their
workers' commitment to a task by rewarding
them in line with expectation of the role
- Builds on the need for a man to get the job done
- Is preoccupied with power, position, perks & politics
- Is mired in daily affairs
- Short-term & hard data oriented
- Focuses on tactical issues
- Relies on human relations to
lubricate human interactions
- Follows & fulfils role expectations by striving
to work effectively within current systems
- Supports structures & systems that maximise
efficiency & guarantee short-term profit
- Covey
- Path Goal Theory
- Based on expectancy theory of motivation
- Leader behaviour is acceptable & satisfying to followers
to the extent that they see it as an immediate source of
satisfaction or instrument to future satisfaction
- Picks from:
- Directive
- Supportive
- Participative
- Achievement-oriented
- House
- Charismatic Leadership
- Builds on transformational leaders,
the antidote to downturn
- Able to motivate, rebuild morale
& promote strong vision for future
- 4 characteristics:
- dominant personality &
desire to influence others
- strong role model behaviour
- articulation of ideological goals
- high expectation of followers
& a confidence that
expectations will be met
- Northouse
- Servant & Team Leadership
- Servant: Leader wishes to
serve his/her people, rather
than a desire to lead or
dictate
- Team: Leaders knowing when to
follow, & importance of leader acting as
team facilitator rather than director
- Knows when to ask questions
- Chooses to delegate & share roles
- Builds on & appreciates diversity
- Seeks out talented people
- Develops colleagues & creates a
sense of mission & purpose
- Belbin
- 4 Types of Senior Teams:
- Informational Teams
- Consultative Teams
- Coordinating Teams
- Decision-making Teams
- Wagerman, Fisher & Hackman
- Distributed Leadership
- All of us can exert a leadership
influence over colleagues, & in
turn influence the direction &
success of the org
- Emphasises importance of
relationships
- Focuses on everyone in the
org as being involved in the
org's future
- Promotes the concept of
emergent leadership, orgs to
develop leaders throughout
org & not just at the top
- Relies on ability of individual
to influence through their
social interactions & not
position
- Emphasises outcomes of
effective leadership, rather
than ability of leaders to
prove themselves competent
in various skills
- Strategic Organisational Leadership
- Rational Strategy Formulation
- Relies on predictability of events
- Emergent Strategy
Formulation
- Emphasises uncertain
conditions & involves
bringing in contingencies
- Strategy Formulation
- Pub Sec Differences:
- Political changes
- Leadership changes
- CG interference
- Variety of stakeholders
- Key Pub Sec Drivers:
- Reducing costs
- Obtaining value for money
- Characteristics of a
successful strategic manager:
- Mixture of sensitivity & toughness
Anmerkungen:
- Sensitivity to gauge both external & internal environments & to assess the risks of failure
- Toughness to persist with strategies to ensure the org is moving in a purposeful direction
- Wisdom to refrain from managing
components of the org but rather
provide leadership
- mapping environ to org & org to environ
- managing interplay bet tasks &
processes when change is required
- Skill to spot leading edge of an activity
- Public Sector Leadership
- Structure
- Lawful delegation of
authority & external controls
that leaders work within
- Craft
- Leaders' behaviours
& personality
- Institution
- Pub sec leader has strong opps
to devise strategy, based on
matching known external
demands with internal motivation
to achieve goals
- Strategic Leadership
- The ability to anticipate, envision, maintain
flexibility & empower others to create the
strategic change necessary
- Exercising Power:
- Mete out resources
- Shape behaviour
through reward &
consequence
- Advance on
multiple fronts
- Make the first move
- Co-opt antagonists
- Remove rivals, if
possible
- Make the vision
compelling
- Make important
relationships
work-no matter what
- Persist
- Use the personal
touch
- Don't draw
unnecessary fire
- Barriers:
- Believe world is
just place &
everything will work
out
- Following socially
acceptable desires for
leaders to be truthful,
modest & self effacing
- Choosing not to
actively seek power,
guarding themselves
from experiencing a
knock to their
self-esteem when they
fail
- Pfeffer
- Selling the vision:
- 1. Establish sense of urgency
- 2. Creating the guiding coalition
- 3. Developing a change vision
- 4. Communicating the change vision
- 5. Empowering broad based action
- 6. Generating short-term wins
- 7. Never letting up
- 8. Incorporating changes into the culture
- Role of Finance Director
- More than just head accountant
- Heart of decision making
- Generating innovative
ideas to solve problems
- Have 'presence'
- Public Engagement
- A structured communication or
dialogue between govt, public &
other interested parties, to inform
specific policy development or
specific service implementation
- More specific than regular stakeholder
engagement-more focussed on specific
policy/service development
- Types:
- Information giving
- Information gathering
- Consultation
- Involvement
- Partnership
- Empowerment
- Ballots, tenant management associations
- Online forums
- Citizen's juries, workshops
- Online, public meetings, surgeries
- Surveys, focus groups
- Leaflets, websites, public meetings
- Collaborative Leadership
- Characteristics to support collaboration:
- Change should be led by most senior people appropriate
- Scale & complexity should be well scoped & maintained
- Common ground should be identified, agreement on problems & outcomes
- Time devoted to understanding perspectives & values of diff parties
- Time & resource devoted to regular & effective communication
- Clear & equitable governance arrangement put in place, with transparent
decision-making & communication about developments
- Partnership working takes time & resources
- Attributes of successful collab leaders:
- Political & strategic awareness
- Interpersonal skills
- Knowledge of the process
- The 8 I's that create successful We's
- Individual excellence
- Importance
- Interdependence
- Investment
- Information
- Integration
- Institutionalisation
- Integrity
- Moss Kanter
- 3 requirements for competitive advantage
of collaboration to be achieved:
- Alliances are living systems that evolve
- Alliances should involve collaboration
rather than mere exchange
- Alliances require a dense web of interpersonal connections
& internal infrastructures that enhance learning
- Innovation & Thought Leadership
- Leaders need to be aware of the culture, capability &
capacity to innovate & support accordingly
- Cultural requirements for innovation:
- Risk taking
- Resources
- Knowledge
- Goals
- Rewards
- Tools
- Relationships
- Thought Leadership
- An entity that is seen as having
creative & innovative ideas
- Sustainability
- Spectrum of pub sec
leadership on
sustainable development
- At risk
- Compliance led
- Incremental
- Strategic
- 9 step model for
achieving sustainable
development
- Make the case
- Build networks
- Link policy with delivery
- Share the learning
- Create a learning culture
- Run demonstration projects
- Skill-up for public engagement
- Hardwire sustainability into financial processes
- Innovate
- Birney, Clarkeson ,
Madden, Porritt &
Tuxworth