are you measuring what you are supposed to be measuring if any extraneous variables you cannot be 100% sure and cannot infer cause and effect
ecological validity
strengths of low eco val research
high control
Nota:
manipulate and isolate the IV to measure the effect on the DV = infer cause and effect
example
Nota:
loftus and palmer changing the verb in the sentance manipulates the iv and allows to see the cause of the different speed estimations
more reliable
Nota:
standardised procedure making it easy to replicate
example
Nota:
bruce conducted an experiment into recognising faces had standadised images and composite images and had to match composties to original = repeated in the same way
high scientific equipment used
Nota:
this is not something we come across every day = objective measurments to be made can collect quantitaive data allowing easy comparisons.
example
Nota:
dement and kleitman when conducting a study on dreaming attatched elctrode to scalp and eye lids, this is not how people normally sleep but gives us indepth information that wouldn't be accsessiable without
weaknesses low of eco val research
reductionist
Nota:
as the situation is very controlled it simplifies complex behavouir by isolating the IV does not look for a combo of factors
generalisability
Nota:
harder to generalise the results as often effected by social desirability and demand characterisitcs due to high levels of control
example
Nota:
dement and kleitman and dreaming - not being allowed caffine and nicotine and being woken up during the night = not generalised to a normal nights sleep
lack of qual data
Nota:
as scientfic methods collect objective quantitaive data and this lacks reason and insight
internal
Nota:
does the study measure what its supposed to within the study itself
external
Nota:
does the study measure what it claims to outside the study
concurrent
Nota:
comparing the measure with an already existing established measure of the same variable to check for concurrent validity
face
Nota:
are you measuring what you say you want to measure
population
Nota:
the extent to which the results of a study can be generalised to the target population